Thanks to Heather for the heads up.
Showing posts with label The Candidate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Candidate. Show all posts
Thursday, August 26, 2010
Monday, May 24, 2010
Spoiler Accuracy Thread
One of our users, BookhouseBoy, from the Forum, has started to compile a couple of interesting threads.
These threads take a look back after an episode has aired and looks at all the spoilers that were posted for it and how much we knew and how accurate our spoilers have been. Thankfully so far it's been pretty damn good ;). All our sources for example all rated What Kate Does as the lowest rated episode out of the 8-9 episodes that they had seen, and this appears to have been the consensus of the fans if you look at the current polls/episode table.
Take a look at threads below. We'll be updating this each week so that those of you who do not follow spoilers can see what was spoiled about the episodes that have aired.
Episode 6.01/6.02 - LA X
Episode 6.03 - What Kate Does
Episode 6.04 - The Substitute
Episode 6.05 - Lighthouse
Episode 6.06 - Sundown
Episode 6.07 - Dr. Linus
Episode 6.08 - Recon
Episode 6.09 - Ab Aeterno
Episode 6.10 - The Package
Episode 6.11 - Happily Ever After
Episode 6.12 - Everybody Love Hugo
Episode 6.13 - The Last Recruit
Episode 6.14 - The Candidate
Episode 6.15 - Across The Sea
Episode 6.16 - What They Died For
Episode 6.17/6.18 - The End
These threads take a look back after an episode has aired and looks at all the spoilers that were posted for it and how much we knew and how accurate our spoilers have been. Thankfully so far it's been pretty damn good ;). All our sources for example all rated What Kate Does as the lowest rated episode out of the 8-9 episodes that they had seen, and this appears to have been the consensus of the fans if you look at the current polls/episode table.
Take a look at threads below. We'll be updating this each week so that those of you who do not follow spoilers can see what was spoiled about the episodes that have aired.
Episode 6.01/6.02 - LA X
Episode 6.03 - What Kate Does
Episode 6.04 - The Substitute
Episode 6.05 - Lighthouse
Episode 6.06 - Sundown
Episode 6.07 - Dr. Linus
Episode 6.08 - Recon
Episode 6.09 - Ab Aeterno
Episode 6.10 - The Package
Episode 6.11 - Happily Ever After
Episode 6.12 - Everybody Love Hugo
Episode 6.13 - The Last Recruit
Episode 6.14 - The Candidate
Episode 6.15 - Across The Sea
Episode 6.16 - What They Died For
Episode 6.17/6.18 - The End
Tuesday, May 11, 2010
Lost Fantasy League: Week 13 Update!
Holy cow, Lost fans! The Fantasy League is cranking up the intensity! Our characters are jockeying for position like soccer moms looking for Silly Bandz! MIB and the Smoke Monster took a dive and that had a huge impact on our leader board. Are you doing better or worse today?
We're T-minus two hours to the next episode, so hang on tight you American viewers! While you wait for the next episode, you can check out all the content here. "The Candidate" wasn't the best episode for points but it definitely set up a lot of interesting scenarios within and outside of the Fantasy League. I'm just as curious as you are to see what happens next (though I'm still bitter about the Kwons).
There were only a few minor point adjustments made, so be sure to check them out in the Important Point Rulings section!
Lost Fantasy Team Lookup Table | LFL on Facebook | G-Man on Twitter | Email G-Man
ODI LOSTcast 68 - Episode 6x14 The Candidate Recap
Hey All,I know we are only hours away from the next episode of LOST, but last week's episode had several action packed emotional and intense scenes! The flash sideways moments were also very important and we discuss each one to provide you our thoughts.
The MiB almost pulled off the long con killing all of the candidates, but Sayid's sacrifice helped a few of them survive and is there still any possibility or reason why he is killing our Losties and it is ok?
Well the podcast for some reason took forever to transcode today, but maybe because it is super-sized! Well it is finally up on iTunes or you can click the link below to find an audio player and download link:
http://the-odi.blogspot.com/2010/05/odi-lostcast-68-episode-6x14-candidate.html
Episode 6x14 The Candidate - LOSTometer Episode Grade Chart
Hey All,
Happy LOST Day!!
So last week's episode 6x14 The Candidate was very emotional and many fans reacted in different ways. Some were quite upset with the writers while most loved the episode. The episode was packed with great action on island and the flash sideways moments off island were filled with some interesting moments.
Many of the news and blog sites said they enjoyed it and the final average grade for the episode was an "A-". This was the first time this season that a grade was on the border and could easily have been an "A" if couple of more grades were higher.
So what did you all think??
Quote of the Week via Lyly: I liked the episode but it shocked me a lot. Maybe it's because I was shocked and why I can't give it an A+ because it would be lying to myself to say I adored it which I don't really since our Losties are dead. I can't enjoy it but it was a great episode, do you understand my dilemma?
Once again thanks to all that are participating and don't forget to check out their sites and recaps at the following links:
DarkUFO | b3rt4 | Karen's LOST Notebook | Vozzek | Jeff Jensen - EW | Ryan McGee - Zap2it | Peter - SlashFilm | Cultural Learnings | Congested | Jay and Jack Podcast | FourToedFoot | DocArzt | SL-LOST | Jopinionated | Washington Post - LOST Bloggers | LOSTzilla | LOST-Media | LOST-Forum | AV Club | Lyly Ford | LOST Mythos Podcast | LOST Blog | F***YeahLOST | Luhks | LOST in Portugal | LOST-Board.de | Seat42F | Rap Basement LOSTIES | LOST in Greece | Find LOST with Carmel | LOST Revisited Now Podcast | PopWrap Blog - NY Post
Source: The ODI
Happy LOST Day!!
So last week's episode 6x14 The Candidate was very emotional and many fans reacted in different ways. Some were quite upset with the writers while most loved the episode. The episode was packed with great action on island and the flash sideways moments off island were filled with some interesting moments.
Many of the news and blog sites said they enjoyed it and the final average grade for the episode was an "A-". This was the first time this season that a grade was on the border and could easily have been an "A" if couple of more grades were higher.
So what did you all think??
Quote of the Week via Lyly: I liked the episode but it shocked me a lot. Maybe it's because I was shocked and why I can't give it an A+ because it would be lying to myself to say I adored it which I don't really since our Losties are dead. I can't enjoy it but it was a great episode, do you understand my dilemma?
Once again thanks to all that are participating and don't forget to check out their sites and recaps at the following links:
DarkUFO | b3rt4 | Karen's LOST Notebook | Vozzek | Jeff Jensen - EW | Ryan McGee - Zap2it | Peter - SlashFilm | Cultural Learnings | Congested | Jay and Jack Podcast | FourToedFoot | DocArzt | SL-LOST | Jopinionated | Washington Post - LOST Bloggers | LOSTzilla | LOST-Media | LOST-Forum | AV Club | Lyly Ford | LOST Mythos Podcast | LOST Blog | F***YeahLOST | Luhks | LOST in Portugal | LOST-Board.de | Seat42F | Rap Basement LOSTIES | LOST in Greece | Find LOST with Carmel | LOST Revisited Now Podcast | PopWrap Blog - NY Post
Source: The ODI
Monday, May 10, 2010
The Spoilered Perspective Podcast: The Candidate
Here's the link for people to download or listen to the "The LOST Spoilered Perspective," covering "The Candidate," hosted by BookhouseBoy and Thirty-Fiver of the SpoilerTV Forums. The Spoilered Perspective recaps the latest episode including all of the information that people who read spoilers knew about the episode ahead of time (but without any actual spoilers for unaired episodes):http://www.talkshoe.com/tc/77072
The podcast is also available at ITunes:
Episode 10, covering 6x15, will be broadcast live at http://www.talkshoe.com/tc/77072 at 8PM EST on Wednesday, May 12th. Fans can also read the text version of the Spoilered Perspective (6x14), where BookhouseBoy makes the self-admitted perhaps ridiculous argument that if you don't count MASSIVE DEATH SPOILERS, the episode was "relatively" unspoiled, here: http://www.spoilertv.co.uk/forum/viewtopic.php?f=17&t=18577
The podcast is also available at ITunes:
Episode 10, covering 6x15, will be broadcast live at http://www.talkshoe.com/tc/77072 at 8PM EST on Wednesday, May 12th. Fans can also read the text version of the Spoilered Perspective (6x14), where BookhouseBoy makes the self-admitted perhaps ridiculous argument that if you don't count MASSIVE DEATH SPOILERS, the episode was "relatively" unspoiled, here: http://www.spoilertv.co.uk/forum/viewtopic.php?f=17&t=18577
Friday, May 7, 2010
UK Viewers - What did you think of Episode 6.14 - The Candidate
Discuss, Comment and Vote in the Poll in the sidebar.
US Episode Poll, Comments and Reactions
Also check out our recaps of The Candidate
Robz888
Vozzek
Sean Furfaro
Other "The Candidate" Related Items
Spoiler Accuracy Thread
US Ratings News
Jorge Garcia Podcast
Lost Untangled
Prediction League Update
Lost Slapdown
MISC
The Candidate - New Mysteries
The Candidate - Episode Screencaps
The Candidate - Related Polls
Episode League Table
You can also discuss it further in our Official Episode Discussion here.
US Episode Poll, Comments and Reactions
Also check out our recaps of The Candidate
Robz888
Vozzek
Sean Furfaro
Other "The Candidate" Related Items
Spoiler Accuracy Thread
US Ratings News
Jorge Garcia Podcast
Lost Untangled
Prediction League Update
Lost Slapdown
MISC
The Candidate - New Mysteries
The Candidate - Episode Screencaps
The Candidate - Related Polls
Episode League Table
You can also discuss it further in our Official Episode Discussion here.
Thursday, May 6, 2010
Wednesday, May 5, 2010
Things I Noticed - "The Candidate" by Vozzek69
THINGS I NOTICED - The Candidate
In case it hadn't occurred to you yet, The Candidate was a slap-in-the-face reminder of one sure thing: the end is drawing near. It had thrills, chills, chaos and death, but it also had a pace that worked really well for how quickly it advanced the storyline. Also, for the first time in a while, there was a solid balance between on and off island... maybe because the alternate timeline scenes were totally excellent this week. Things I Noticed:
I'll See You That Mortar Strike, and Raise You a Hit-and-Run Accident
Maybe it's because the timelines seem to be merging, or pehaps it's because we now have six seasons of the show for comparison. Either way, the parallels and mirror image scenes on LOST have been increasing geometrically. Jack saving Locke's life off-island is reflected by Locke saving Jack's back at the beach, and that's without even going into the constant repetition of dialogue this episode.
Locke's guilt over his accident is holding him back, keeping him from believing he deserves a second chance. Later on Jack would hand him some sincere and poignant reasons for wiping the Tabula Rasa, but for right now Locke is content to keep things the way they are. That's when we see that maybe Jack hasn't changed at all. Although he's fixed the David situation, he still can't stop trying to save everyone. Locke's problem? He still hasn't learned to put himself first.
As we see later on, both of these characters need to let go. By still clinging to their old ideologies, they're still unable to 'see' the truth. For Desmond, it took a stark visual reminder in the form of Charlie underwater. But for Jack and Locke... throughout duplicated scenarios and repeat dialogue, these characters still don't get it. They're still blinded by the inability to break out of their old bad habits. They simple can't see the forest for the trees... despite Bernard handing Jack a chainsaw and practically pull-starting it for him this episode.
This Just In: Kate Austen is Officially Superfluous
Six years later, it's disappointing to see that Sawyer still hasn't learned. Every single time you hand the rifle back to someone after disarming (and humiliating) them, they're going to nail you right in the balls with it. In complying with "put the gun down", just for once I'd like to see Sawyer chuck it into the jungle, making the poor asshole have to go pick it up and saving his balls in the process. Nice disarm on doughboy though.
In all honesty, when Widmore first got to the island I thought he was going to be a refreshing change when it came to getting some direct answers. The way he spoke so frankly to Jin after capturing him seemed pretty legit, and I was hoping for some oldschool enlightenment. Turns out I was wrong. Charles Widmore is the same cryptic, dickish ringleader as everyone else, locking our heroes in a cage at gunpoint without even a hint of explanation other than the old standby: "It's for your own good."
His only real contribution so far? Bringing Desmond to the island. That, and letting us know that Kate never had any true purpose on the island at all. Either this makes her character totally redundant, or she's still somehow flying under everyone's radar. The jury's still out on that one, but I really want to know why Jacob touched her nose.
Bernard's Face: Full of Smug, Knowing Answers or Just Bonelessly Creepy?
The answer is BOTH. Not only are Bernard's facial expressions creepy in a horrified Gumby sort of way, but the man is also totally in on things. The dialogue he shares with Jack lends assloads of credence to my original theory that both Rose and Bernard know what's going on... both on the island during The Incident and off the island in the flash-sideways timeline.
"You mind if I ask you why you're so interested in Mr. Locke... Jack?" Listen to Bernard casually add Jack's name to the end of that sentence, as if they're old island buddies. Also watch the knowing smile that crosses Bernard's face immediately afterward, as Jack searches for the answer to his question. "Oceanic 815. Pretty weird huh? Maybe you're onto something, here."
It's more than obvious that Bernard knows. Just as he couldn't stop Juliet from marching off to her death by giving her direct answers, he can't tell Jack exactly what he needs to know. "I can't break patient confidentiality and tell you something I shouldn't. This is a punch-to-the-gut metaphor for "I can't pull back the curtain Jack, you need to do that yourself." Bernard does skirt the line however, sending Jack in the right direction by writing him a quick prescription for the truth.
In many ways, the whole situation is reminiscent of Locke's words to Charlie, all the way back during The Moth. Bernard could take his knife, gently widen the opening, and allow Jack to go free. If he did this however, Jack might be too weak to survive. The struggle - in this case, the struggle for personal growth - is the very thing that strengthens the person in question. It prepares him for the world outside the cocoon... or in this case, outside the realm of the island.
There's also one recurring thread woven throughout the alternate timeline, and it gets mentioned again here by Bernard: 3 years. Everything important that happened in our character's lives seemed to have occurred three years ago. Since the flash-sideways timeline presumably takes place in 2004, that puts Locke's accident somewhere in 2001, and this means little to us. Yet if we believe this person to be our Bernard - the lovable dentist who remembers spending three years on the island with Rose, Vincent, and a shitload of canned goods - then to him it's actually 2007 right now.
This may solve the single biggest problem most people have with assuming the real and sideways universe can't be running concurrently: the fact that they're separated by three years. Yet when you start viewing things from the perspective of someone like Rose or Bernard, it actually synchs up the two timelines nicely. These people have already lived those years, and even characters who've died (Charlie, Libby, Keamy, etc..) may have also experienced that same amount of time go by. Perhaps it somehow is 2007, and the rest of our characters have yet to realize it.
That whole theory's pretty kooky, and it admittedly still needs lots of work. I'm open to anything that supports it or tears it down, but either way, the repeated reference to 3 years is definitely something we should explore further.
Welcome... To HYDRA ISLAND!
That seemed kinda off, didn't it? I guess with all the canoe-trips and flip-flopping between storylines (and timelines), the writers felt the need to explain exactly where we are these days. And while we're on the subject of flip-flopping, let's talk briefly about the difference between night and day.
Continuity errors aside, there has to be something up with the passing of time on the island. Over the past several weeks we've watched night turn to day in a just matter of hours, and vice versa. This week's episode was no different, and these huge gaps in time are getting to the point where they're actually pretty distracting.
As Sawyer tells Kate, it feels like we're running in circles. Timewise, those circles now seem to be getting smaller and smaller. If this is intentional, perhaps the island is shifting or moving through time, as we saw way back in season four with Daniel's rocket. Also remember how night turned to day when Frank flew the chopper to the freighter, and how the same thing happened when Frank flew Ajira 316 back to the island. Day and night mean very little when it comes to the time storm surrounding the island, and if that storm is moving (or the circle of the island's influence slowly closing) it could explain many of these changes.
Back on the beach, the dark man flat out lies to Jack's face - and Jack almost seems to know it. Unfortunately he doesn't fully piece everything together until later on, when he sees the bomb. "I could kill you Jack, right here, right now", the dark man tells him. "And I could kill every single one of your friends, and there's not a thing that you can do to stop me."
Examine Terry O'Quinn's mannerisms and you'll see a lot of suppressed frustration here. As viewers, we already know his words aren't true. The MIB can't touch the candidates directly, as the boy in the jungle has so laughingly reminded him. Flocke has had to play follow the leader for most of this season, and at this point his patience is wearing very thin. Just as he thought the game was over, he's had to come up with yet another loophole - this time one to kill off the candidates - and now on top of this, Jack suddenly doesn't want to leave the island. We already know the man in black is way past the point of wanting to still play games, and yet countermoves are somehow still being executed against him.
One more thing about this scene: the top half of Locke's scar is gone. Maybe it's nothing, or maybe it's something... but it was very, very noticeable. Going out on a limb, maybe it somehow represents the merging of timelines - the transition of scar-free LAX_Locke back to the island. Or maybe (if you're still on board with the whole Jacob/MIB being two halves of a whole idea), Jacob's essence is slowly healing that scar. Kind of far fetched, but it did stick out in my mind.
Two Dozen Sonic Fence Posts? Check. Pair of Giant Donut Magnets? Check. GPS-guided Mortar? Check. Backup Generator? Uh oh...
And so, in the end, Charles Widmore's master plan is foiled by a complete lack of foresight. In the blink of an eye, his once sharp-looking crew of monster-hunting veterans are reduced to a bunch of panic-stricken freshmen, shooting rifles into the jungle that may just as well have been water pistols.
So I'm watching this scene thinking: "Wait... are Widmore's people really shooting at the smoke monster? Really???" Yup. And again, this kinda sucks. While the monster scenes are always cool to watch, I was expecting a hell of a lot more out of Widmore. Unlike Bram or Illana, Charles spent a lot of time on the island. You'd think he should know better. At the very least though, smokie's infiltration of Widmore's encampment paves the way for a rather predictible and joyous upcoming event: the death of Zoe (let's hope).
It All Comes Back Around... Especially If You're Anthony Cooper
Jack's tireless efforts to fix things, tempered by Bernard's gentle elbow to the ribcage, puts him at the nursing home of Anthony Cooper. Helen tries talking Jack out of continuing his investigation with: "You saved John. Why can't that be enough?" And Jack, speaking for all of us, answers back quite simply: "Because it's not."
Damn straight, Jack. At this point, nothing is enough. With only a few hours of LOST left, I expect each week to be a whole avalanche of answers. And if you're going to introduce yet another strange mystery (i.e. how Locke and his dad got hurt), you'd better answer that mystery within the same damned episode, just like you did right here.
Anyway, as Helen wheeled a catatonic Anthony Cooper into view I was reminded sharply of two things. One was Captain Pike of the original Star Trek. The second? The guy sitting in the old chair back at Jacob's cabin, the one who eerily called out "Help me..."
There are a lot of ways to explain Cooper's vegetative state, but none of them are definitive. It's entirely possible his condition is purely physiological; the result of Locke's bad pilotage. Still, I can't help but think of George Minkowski, or Daniel's girlfriend Theresa. The Anthony Cooper we see here has a strangely haunted look to him, as if a large part of him were missing. With so little time left we might never really know, but in the back of my own mind I keep hearing that guy in the cabin calling for help. And if anyone on LOST deserves to be time-stuck in some kind of jaunt-like limbo hell, we can all agree that it's Coop.
Somebody Set Us Up The Bomb. Still Not Sure Who It Was
The Ajira plane has always been a bone of contention with me. It's never sat well that LOST could end with our main characters just flying off into the sunset, and if Frank were at the helm the whole thing would be even more campy. At times I could even picture him pulling back on the control wheel just as he ran out of runway, open shirt flapping wildly, landing gear skimming the tree-tops as Frank wiped sweat from his brow and made wisecracks about things being "too close for comfort". Ugh.
So yeah, I for one was happy to see the plane wired to explode. But who exactly did it? Widmore's people would be the most logical answer of course, but it seems pretty silly for Charles to think he could just blow up the smoke monster. And since I never once believed the man in black would escape the island by airplane, I can only assume Widmore would be thinking along those lines too.
So did Flocke wire the plane to go off? Makes sense, if you think about it. He wants all the candidates dead in one fell swoop, and by wiring the explosives to the electrical system he's allowing them to kill themselves by powering the airplane up. Maybe once Jack announced he wasn't leaving the island, Flocke decided on a whole different plan - the submarine. He does take the dead guy's wristwatch before 'discovering' the explosives, and on the fly, quickly improvises a bomb.
Could've also been the Ben/Richard/Miles triple-threat, but I'd imagine they would've set the bomb off right away rather than rig it to go off later on. Who the hell knows. One thing's for sure though: when Locke talks about Widmore "gathering everyone in one spot" and the trying to kill them? He's actually talking about his own plan. Coming out of the airplane and immediately showing off those bricks of C-4 was a great way to gain the trust and credibility Flocke would later use to manipulate everyone onto the sub.
In the Alt-Universe, That Vending Machine Works Just Fine
In the LAX timeline we're shown a tremendous array of parallels and mirror images, including a shot of Jack and Claire even looking into a mirror together. Jack's Apollo bar falls this time, no push needed. Catch a Rising Star plays on a Claire's new music box. The two of them have a "Wow we took the exact same flight from Sydney!" moment, which in my opinion is getting pretty stale by now. Jack even offers Claire a family-friendly invitation to stay with him, in an effort to make up for lost time.
The most interesting things we get however, are the semi-conscious rantings of John Locke. His island experiences are crossing over to the LAX timeline, including memories of pushing the button. Locke even utters the phrase "I wish you had believed me", directly from his suicide note.
Things are moving faster and faster in the alt. Almost every single scene contains a parallel to some prior event or line of dialogue. Just as things on the island are accelerating, the same is happening in the off-island world. I think that's what they're trying to show us with all of this recycled imagery.
Sayid Can Snap the Most Necks, but Jack's Got the Meanest Rifle-Face, Hands Down
"John Locke told me I needed to stay." It was an awesome line, made ten times more awesome by Jack following it up by shoving the MIB into the water. I was pretty sure all hell was going to break loose after that, and of course it did. But after the many references to his aversion to water, I also expected the dark man to be a lot more affected than he seemed to be. Instead, he just got wet.
Apparently Jack's not a man who believes in cover. As we saw from his A-Team days in Dharma, Jack's reaction to being shot at is pretty standard: march toward your enemy with a sneer and an outstretched arm, firing the whole time. It's almost as if Jack knows he's invincible, or doesn't really care. All that matters to him at this point is getting his friends off the island.
The ensuing shootout took place exactly the way Flocke wanted it, all the way down to the very last detail: Sawyer locking him out of the submarine. It stands to reason that the MIB knew of Sawyer's distrust the whole time, even after he'd thanked him outside of that airplane. Understand that the dark man's been playing these types of games for centuries, unwillingly or not. Over hundreds of years and with an advesary like Jacob? He's gotten very, very good at manipulation.
His last move is a good one: planting a bomb that can only be triggered by the person who is holding it. This is where the MIB finally puts Sawyer in checkmate... as much as Sawyer mistrusts the smoke monster, his distrust of Jack is equally great. After what happened to Juliet, Sawyer's not one for letting things just 'play out'. This is why he can't watch the bomb's timer count harmlessly down to zero, and this is why he triggers the real bomb by yanking out the fake battery leads.
It's Jack who figures things out, and he actually does it in time to save everyone. Logically, the whole thing is pretty simple: if the MIB wanted them all dead, he would've killed them if he could. Why go through the trouble of a hastily rigged bomb when he could just smoke anyone at any time? "What if he hasn't killed us because he's not allowed to?" Jack asks his captive audience. "What if he's trying to get us to kill each other?"
Bingo, yet Sawyer just can't see it. Jack's words of "nothing's going to happen" are echoed in season two, where he tells Locke the same thing about pushing the button. These words are repeated again that season by Locke when he loses faith in the button and tells Eko the same exact thing. In both those cases the button gets pushed anyway, just as Sawyer pushes another type of button right here, right now. And upon doing so, Sawyer inadvertently sends a few more people to the other side.
Pushing the proverbial button is and always has been LOST's ultimate test of faith. It defines what's real and what's not real. It separates the idea of unalterable fate from the power to actually write your own destiny. When you boil everything else down far enough, it's the essence of the entire show.
Because It's Going To Be You, Jack
I took Sayid's last words as pretty inarguable evidence that Jack is indeed the candidate. I'm sure someone will argue it of course, but definitely not with me.
It always sucks to see our main characters die, knowing we'll never see them in action again. Even on LOST, where the dead can show up at any time, losing someone we've known and loved for so long can really sting... even on a TV show. Sayid was certainly one of LOST's best characters. And although we probably lost him a half dozen or so episodes ago, it was good to see him go out doing something both redeeming and important. Martyring himself here, just as he and Essam had planned to do way back in season one, was certainly something Sayid did for The Greater Good.
It's also comforting to recognize that Sayid made it as far as he did. Knowing LOST will end in three weeks takes a lot of the sting out of losing even the oldest and most kickass of characters. Every time you get the urge to dust off your LOST disc set, it'll be nice to remember that no matter what happens you've got nearly six full seasons of Sayid. And in each one of them, he's snapping a bunch of necks.
Frank! You Could've Been a Contender...
Just as Lapidus almost kicked open the cage door this episode, his character almost mattered. Don't get me wrong, because I love Frank. He had lots of potential. The problem is, he was never really allowed to live up to it. As the story progressed and new people kept coming, they allowed Frank Lapidus to fall by the wayside. His once cool character degenerated into a syrupy mess of comedic one-liners, and along with it, any importance he might've once had.
Maybe I'm wrong, but I got the feeling the writers never really had a solid ending for Frank. At some point they just started using him to take the edge off the more serious happenings on the show. What sucks most is that Frank isn't even acknowledged at the end of this episode, when everyone washes up on the beach. Even Nikki and Paulo got a eulogy, but all Frank got was a "Where's Sun and Jin?"
RIP Frank. If you are on the other side, I hope you're drinking from a hollowed-out pineapple and wearing a Hawaiian shirt unbuttoned down to your navel.
Sun and Jin...
Of all the main character deaths we've seen, I have to say I'm most satisfied with what happened to Sun and Jin. The actors did a fantastic job, and the scene was exceptionally well done. Most important of all, the whole thing just felt right to me. Much like the ring Sun puts back on Jin's finger earlier in the episode, their story had truly come full circle.
On-island, Sun and Jin's time was up. They existed only for each other, and once reunited they had completed their journey. Through marital troubles, infidelity, infertility and just about the worst father-in-law imaginable, the two of them eventually recognized that the most important thing was just being together. They stopped taking their love for granted, as Jacob mentioned at their wedding.
I also got the distinct feeling that because their transformation was complete, Sun and Jin were being taken "out" of the island's playing field. In short, Sun wasn't pinned to that wall by accident. There was simply nothing left for either of them to learn.
The final scene of Sun and Jin holding hands could've been a great way to end their story, but we were purposefully shown an image of their hands letting go. To me, this was representative of them not letting go of each other, but of the island timeline itself. It's comforting to know that Sun and Jin still exist on the other side, and that they're happy, content, and ready to start their new life with a baby on the way.
Maybe Everyone Should Just Stay Away From Planes For a While
As if the whole sub debacle wasn't enough, the last scene between LAX Jack and Locke just totally kicked ass. Jack is recognizing the need for both of them to let go of certain things: for Locke it's his guilt, and for Jack it's his constant need for control. The words they exchange are incredibly sincere, and Locke's story involving that plane crash was so well acted I almost believed it actually happened. It was another great scene, much like the one they shared at LAX.
"You go first." Right now, I'd like to predict that these are Jack's words to Locke in one of the final scenes of LOST. If Jack becomes the new Jacob and Locke becomes the new monster, the game begins all over again. Two players, two sides, and of course one of them has to make the first move.
Jack's parting words of "I wish you'd believed me" seemed to trigger even more memories for John, and it gave him a significant amount of pause. Locke also recognized and did a double-take upon seeing Jin in the hallway. I'm hoping these small flashes of recollection evolve into full-blown memories of island events, because in doing so it would bring our real characters full circle.
On island, Jack marching purposefully into the ocean and crying up at the sky seemed to say one thing: "Okay, I accept my position. But please, no more sacrifice."
Next week looks Ab Aeterno awesome.
In case it hadn't occurred to you yet, The Candidate was a slap-in-the-face reminder of one sure thing: the end is drawing near. It had thrills, chills, chaos and death, but it also had a pace that worked really well for how quickly it advanced the storyline. Also, for the first time in a while, there was a solid balance between on and off island... maybe because the alternate timeline scenes were totally excellent this week. Things I Noticed:
I'll See You That Mortar Strike, and Raise You a Hit-and-Run Accident
Maybe it's because the timelines seem to be merging, or pehaps it's because we now have six seasons of the show for comparison. Either way, the parallels and mirror image scenes on LOST have been increasing geometrically. Jack saving Locke's life off-island is reflected by Locke saving Jack's back at the beach, and that's without even going into the constant repetition of dialogue this episode.
Locke's guilt over his accident is holding him back, keeping him from believing he deserves a second chance. Later on Jack would hand him some sincere and poignant reasons for wiping the Tabula Rasa, but for right now Locke is content to keep things the way they are. That's when we see that maybe Jack hasn't changed at all. Although he's fixed the David situation, he still can't stop trying to save everyone. Locke's problem? He still hasn't learned to put himself first.
As we see later on, both of these characters need to let go. By still clinging to their old ideologies, they're still unable to 'see' the truth. For Desmond, it took a stark visual reminder in the form of Charlie underwater. But for Jack and Locke... throughout duplicated scenarios and repeat dialogue, these characters still don't get it. They're still blinded by the inability to break out of their old bad habits. They simple can't see the forest for the trees... despite Bernard handing Jack a chainsaw and practically pull-starting it for him this episode.
This Just In: Kate Austen is Officially Superfluous
Six years later, it's disappointing to see that Sawyer still hasn't learned. Every single time you hand the rifle back to someone after disarming (and humiliating) them, they're going to nail you right in the balls with it. In complying with "put the gun down", just for once I'd like to see Sawyer chuck it into the jungle, making the poor asshole have to go pick it up and saving his balls in the process. Nice disarm on doughboy though.
In all honesty, when Widmore first got to the island I thought he was going to be a refreshing change when it came to getting some direct answers. The way he spoke so frankly to Jin after capturing him seemed pretty legit, and I was hoping for some oldschool enlightenment. Turns out I was wrong. Charles Widmore is the same cryptic, dickish ringleader as everyone else, locking our heroes in a cage at gunpoint without even a hint of explanation other than the old standby: "It's for your own good."
His only real contribution so far? Bringing Desmond to the island. That, and letting us know that Kate never had any true purpose on the island at all. Either this makes her character totally redundant, or she's still somehow flying under everyone's radar. The jury's still out on that one, but I really want to know why Jacob touched her nose.
Bernard's Face: Full of Smug, Knowing Answers or Just Bonelessly Creepy?
The answer is BOTH. Not only are Bernard's facial expressions creepy in a horrified Gumby sort of way, but the man is also totally in on things. The dialogue he shares with Jack lends assloads of credence to my original theory that both Rose and Bernard know what's going on... both on the island during The Incident and off the island in the flash-sideways timeline.
"You mind if I ask you why you're so interested in Mr. Locke... Jack?" Listen to Bernard casually add Jack's name to the end of that sentence, as if they're old island buddies. Also watch the knowing smile that crosses Bernard's face immediately afterward, as Jack searches for the answer to his question. "Oceanic 815. Pretty weird huh? Maybe you're onto something, here."
It's more than obvious that Bernard knows. Just as he couldn't stop Juliet from marching off to her death by giving her direct answers, he can't tell Jack exactly what he needs to know. "I can't break patient confidentiality and tell you something I shouldn't. This is a punch-to-the-gut metaphor for "I can't pull back the curtain Jack, you need to do that yourself." Bernard does skirt the line however, sending Jack in the right direction by writing him a quick prescription for the truth.
In many ways, the whole situation is reminiscent of Locke's words to Charlie, all the way back during The Moth. Bernard could take his knife, gently widen the opening, and allow Jack to go free. If he did this however, Jack might be too weak to survive. The struggle - in this case, the struggle for personal growth - is the very thing that strengthens the person in question. It prepares him for the world outside the cocoon... or in this case, outside the realm of the island.
There's also one recurring thread woven throughout the alternate timeline, and it gets mentioned again here by Bernard: 3 years. Everything important that happened in our character's lives seemed to have occurred three years ago. Since the flash-sideways timeline presumably takes place in 2004, that puts Locke's accident somewhere in 2001, and this means little to us. Yet if we believe this person to be our Bernard - the lovable dentist who remembers spending three years on the island with Rose, Vincent, and a shitload of canned goods - then to him it's actually 2007 right now.
This may solve the single biggest problem most people have with assuming the real and sideways universe can't be running concurrently: the fact that they're separated by three years. Yet when you start viewing things from the perspective of someone like Rose or Bernard, it actually synchs up the two timelines nicely. These people have already lived those years, and even characters who've died (Charlie, Libby, Keamy, etc..) may have also experienced that same amount of time go by. Perhaps it somehow is 2007, and the rest of our characters have yet to realize it.
That whole theory's pretty kooky, and it admittedly still needs lots of work. I'm open to anything that supports it or tears it down, but either way, the repeated reference to 3 years is definitely something we should explore further.
Welcome... To HYDRA ISLAND!
That seemed kinda off, didn't it? I guess with all the canoe-trips and flip-flopping between storylines (and timelines), the writers felt the need to explain exactly where we are these days. And while we're on the subject of flip-flopping, let's talk briefly about the difference between night and day.
Continuity errors aside, there has to be something up with the passing of time on the island. Over the past several weeks we've watched night turn to day in a just matter of hours, and vice versa. This week's episode was no different, and these huge gaps in time are getting to the point where they're actually pretty distracting.
As Sawyer tells Kate, it feels like we're running in circles. Timewise, those circles now seem to be getting smaller and smaller. If this is intentional, perhaps the island is shifting or moving through time, as we saw way back in season four with Daniel's rocket. Also remember how night turned to day when Frank flew the chopper to the freighter, and how the same thing happened when Frank flew Ajira 316 back to the island. Day and night mean very little when it comes to the time storm surrounding the island, and if that storm is moving (or the circle of the island's influence slowly closing) it could explain many of these changes.
Back on the beach, the dark man flat out lies to Jack's face - and Jack almost seems to know it. Unfortunately he doesn't fully piece everything together until later on, when he sees the bomb. "I could kill you Jack, right here, right now", the dark man tells him. "And I could kill every single one of your friends, and there's not a thing that you can do to stop me."
Examine Terry O'Quinn's mannerisms and you'll see a lot of suppressed frustration here. As viewers, we already know his words aren't true. The MIB can't touch the candidates directly, as the boy in the jungle has so laughingly reminded him. Flocke has had to play follow the leader for most of this season, and at this point his patience is wearing very thin. Just as he thought the game was over, he's had to come up with yet another loophole - this time one to kill off the candidates - and now on top of this, Jack suddenly doesn't want to leave the island. We already know the man in black is way past the point of wanting to still play games, and yet countermoves are somehow still being executed against him.
One more thing about this scene: the top half of Locke's scar is gone. Maybe it's nothing, or maybe it's something... but it was very, very noticeable. Going out on a limb, maybe it somehow represents the merging of timelines - the transition of scar-free LAX_Locke back to the island. Or maybe (if you're still on board with the whole Jacob/MIB being two halves of a whole idea), Jacob's essence is slowly healing that scar. Kind of far fetched, but it did stick out in my mind.
Two Dozen Sonic Fence Posts? Check. Pair of Giant Donut Magnets? Check. GPS-guided Mortar? Check. Backup Generator? Uh oh...
And so, in the end, Charles Widmore's master plan is foiled by a complete lack of foresight. In the blink of an eye, his once sharp-looking crew of monster-hunting veterans are reduced to a bunch of panic-stricken freshmen, shooting rifles into the jungle that may just as well have been water pistols.
So I'm watching this scene thinking: "Wait... are Widmore's people really shooting at the smoke monster? Really???" Yup. And again, this kinda sucks. While the monster scenes are always cool to watch, I was expecting a hell of a lot more out of Widmore. Unlike Bram or Illana, Charles spent a lot of time on the island. You'd think he should know better. At the very least though, smokie's infiltration of Widmore's encampment paves the way for a rather predictible and joyous upcoming event: the death of Zoe (let's hope).
It All Comes Back Around... Especially If You're Anthony Cooper
Jack's tireless efforts to fix things, tempered by Bernard's gentle elbow to the ribcage, puts him at the nursing home of Anthony Cooper. Helen tries talking Jack out of continuing his investigation with: "You saved John. Why can't that be enough?" And Jack, speaking for all of us, answers back quite simply: "Because it's not."
Damn straight, Jack. At this point, nothing is enough. With only a few hours of LOST left, I expect each week to be a whole avalanche of answers. And if you're going to introduce yet another strange mystery (i.e. how Locke and his dad got hurt), you'd better answer that mystery within the same damned episode, just like you did right here.
Anyway, as Helen wheeled a catatonic Anthony Cooper into view I was reminded sharply of two things. One was Captain Pike of the original Star Trek. The second? The guy sitting in the old chair back at Jacob's cabin, the one who eerily called out "Help me..."
There are a lot of ways to explain Cooper's vegetative state, but none of them are definitive. It's entirely possible his condition is purely physiological; the result of Locke's bad pilotage. Still, I can't help but think of George Minkowski, or Daniel's girlfriend Theresa. The Anthony Cooper we see here has a strangely haunted look to him, as if a large part of him were missing. With so little time left we might never really know, but in the back of my own mind I keep hearing that guy in the cabin calling for help. And if anyone on LOST deserves to be time-stuck in some kind of jaunt-like limbo hell, we can all agree that it's Coop.
Somebody Set Us Up The Bomb. Still Not Sure Who It Was
The Ajira plane has always been a bone of contention with me. It's never sat well that LOST could end with our main characters just flying off into the sunset, and if Frank were at the helm the whole thing would be even more campy. At times I could even picture him pulling back on the control wheel just as he ran out of runway, open shirt flapping wildly, landing gear skimming the tree-tops as Frank wiped sweat from his brow and made wisecracks about things being "too close for comfort". Ugh.
So yeah, I for one was happy to see the plane wired to explode. But who exactly did it? Widmore's people would be the most logical answer of course, but it seems pretty silly for Charles to think he could just blow up the smoke monster. And since I never once believed the man in black would escape the island by airplane, I can only assume Widmore would be thinking along those lines too.
So did Flocke wire the plane to go off? Makes sense, if you think about it. He wants all the candidates dead in one fell swoop, and by wiring the explosives to the electrical system he's allowing them to kill themselves by powering the airplane up. Maybe once Jack announced he wasn't leaving the island, Flocke decided on a whole different plan - the submarine. He does take the dead guy's wristwatch before 'discovering' the explosives, and on the fly, quickly improvises a bomb.
Could've also been the Ben/Richard/Miles triple-threat, but I'd imagine they would've set the bomb off right away rather than rig it to go off later on. Who the hell knows. One thing's for sure though: when Locke talks about Widmore "gathering everyone in one spot" and the trying to kill them? He's actually talking about his own plan. Coming out of the airplane and immediately showing off those bricks of C-4 was a great way to gain the trust and credibility Flocke would later use to manipulate everyone onto the sub.
In the Alt-Universe, That Vending Machine Works Just Fine
In the LAX timeline we're shown a tremendous array of parallels and mirror images, including a shot of Jack and Claire even looking into a mirror together. Jack's Apollo bar falls this time, no push needed. Catch a Rising Star plays on a Claire's new music box. The two of them have a "Wow we took the exact same flight from Sydney!" moment, which in my opinion is getting pretty stale by now. Jack even offers Claire a family-friendly invitation to stay with him, in an effort to make up for lost time.
The most interesting things we get however, are the semi-conscious rantings of John Locke. His island experiences are crossing over to the LAX timeline, including memories of pushing the button. Locke even utters the phrase "I wish you had believed me", directly from his suicide note.
Things are moving faster and faster in the alt. Almost every single scene contains a parallel to some prior event or line of dialogue. Just as things on the island are accelerating, the same is happening in the off-island world. I think that's what they're trying to show us with all of this recycled imagery.
Sayid Can Snap the Most Necks, but Jack's Got the Meanest Rifle-Face, Hands Down
"John Locke told me I needed to stay." It was an awesome line, made ten times more awesome by Jack following it up by shoving the MIB into the water. I was pretty sure all hell was going to break loose after that, and of course it did. But after the many references to his aversion to water, I also expected the dark man to be a lot more affected than he seemed to be. Instead, he just got wet.
Apparently Jack's not a man who believes in cover. As we saw from his A-Team days in Dharma, Jack's reaction to being shot at is pretty standard: march toward your enemy with a sneer and an outstretched arm, firing the whole time. It's almost as if Jack knows he's invincible, or doesn't really care. All that matters to him at this point is getting his friends off the island.
The ensuing shootout took place exactly the way Flocke wanted it, all the way down to the very last detail: Sawyer locking him out of the submarine. It stands to reason that the MIB knew of Sawyer's distrust the whole time, even after he'd thanked him outside of that airplane. Understand that the dark man's been playing these types of games for centuries, unwillingly or not. Over hundreds of years and with an advesary like Jacob? He's gotten very, very good at manipulation.
His last move is a good one: planting a bomb that can only be triggered by the person who is holding it. This is where the MIB finally puts Sawyer in checkmate... as much as Sawyer mistrusts the smoke monster, his distrust of Jack is equally great. After what happened to Juliet, Sawyer's not one for letting things just 'play out'. This is why he can't watch the bomb's timer count harmlessly down to zero, and this is why he triggers the real bomb by yanking out the fake battery leads.
It's Jack who figures things out, and he actually does it in time to save everyone. Logically, the whole thing is pretty simple: if the MIB wanted them all dead, he would've killed them if he could. Why go through the trouble of a hastily rigged bomb when he could just smoke anyone at any time? "What if he hasn't killed us because he's not allowed to?" Jack asks his captive audience. "What if he's trying to get us to kill each other?"
Bingo, yet Sawyer just can't see it. Jack's words of "nothing's going to happen" are echoed in season two, where he tells Locke the same thing about pushing the button. These words are repeated again that season by Locke when he loses faith in the button and tells Eko the same exact thing. In both those cases the button gets pushed anyway, just as Sawyer pushes another type of button right here, right now. And upon doing so, Sawyer inadvertently sends a few more people to the other side.
Pushing the proverbial button is and always has been LOST's ultimate test of faith. It defines what's real and what's not real. It separates the idea of unalterable fate from the power to actually write your own destiny. When you boil everything else down far enough, it's the essence of the entire show.
Because It's Going To Be You, Jack
I took Sayid's last words as pretty inarguable evidence that Jack is indeed the candidate. I'm sure someone will argue it of course, but definitely not with me.
It always sucks to see our main characters die, knowing we'll never see them in action again. Even on LOST, where the dead can show up at any time, losing someone we've known and loved for so long can really sting... even on a TV show. Sayid was certainly one of LOST's best characters. And although we probably lost him a half dozen or so episodes ago, it was good to see him go out doing something both redeeming and important. Martyring himself here, just as he and Essam had planned to do way back in season one, was certainly something Sayid did for The Greater Good.
It's also comforting to recognize that Sayid made it as far as he did. Knowing LOST will end in three weeks takes a lot of the sting out of losing even the oldest and most kickass of characters. Every time you get the urge to dust off your LOST disc set, it'll be nice to remember that no matter what happens you've got nearly six full seasons of Sayid. And in each one of them, he's snapping a bunch of necks.
Frank! You Could've Been a Contender...
Just as Lapidus almost kicked open the cage door this episode, his character almost mattered. Don't get me wrong, because I love Frank. He had lots of potential. The problem is, he was never really allowed to live up to it. As the story progressed and new people kept coming, they allowed Frank Lapidus to fall by the wayside. His once cool character degenerated into a syrupy mess of comedic one-liners, and along with it, any importance he might've once had.
Maybe I'm wrong, but I got the feeling the writers never really had a solid ending for Frank. At some point they just started using him to take the edge off the more serious happenings on the show. What sucks most is that Frank isn't even acknowledged at the end of this episode, when everyone washes up on the beach. Even Nikki and Paulo got a eulogy, but all Frank got was a "Where's Sun and Jin?"
RIP Frank. If you are on the other side, I hope you're drinking from a hollowed-out pineapple and wearing a Hawaiian shirt unbuttoned down to your navel.
Sun and Jin...
Of all the main character deaths we've seen, I have to say I'm most satisfied with what happened to Sun and Jin. The actors did a fantastic job, and the scene was exceptionally well done. Most important of all, the whole thing just felt right to me. Much like the ring Sun puts back on Jin's finger earlier in the episode, their story had truly come full circle.
On-island, Sun and Jin's time was up. They existed only for each other, and once reunited they had completed their journey. Through marital troubles, infidelity, infertility and just about the worst father-in-law imaginable, the two of them eventually recognized that the most important thing was just being together. They stopped taking their love for granted, as Jacob mentioned at their wedding.
I also got the distinct feeling that because their transformation was complete, Sun and Jin were being taken "out" of the island's playing field. In short, Sun wasn't pinned to that wall by accident. There was simply nothing left for either of them to learn.
The final scene of Sun and Jin holding hands could've been a great way to end their story, but we were purposefully shown an image of their hands letting go. To me, this was representative of them not letting go of each other, but of the island timeline itself. It's comforting to know that Sun and Jin still exist on the other side, and that they're happy, content, and ready to start their new life with a baby on the way.
Maybe Everyone Should Just Stay Away From Planes For a While
As if the whole sub debacle wasn't enough, the last scene between LAX Jack and Locke just totally kicked ass. Jack is recognizing the need for both of them to let go of certain things: for Locke it's his guilt, and for Jack it's his constant need for control. The words they exchange are incredibly sincere, and Locke's story involving that plane crash was so well acted I almost believed it actually happened. It was another great scene, much like the one they shared at LAX.
"You go first." Right now, I'd like to predict that these are Jack's words to Locke in one of the final scenes of LOST. If Jack becomes the new Jacob and Locke becomes the new monster, the game begins all over again. Two players, two sides, and of course one of them has to make the first move.
Jack's parting words of "I wish you'd believed me" seemed to trigger even more memories for John, and it gave him a significant amount of pause. Locke also recognized and did a double-take upon seeing Jin in the hallway. I'm hoping these small flashes of recollection evolve into full-blown memories of island events, because in doing so it would bring our real characters full circle.
On island, Jack marching purposefully into the ocean and crying up at the sky seemed to say one thing: "Okay, I accept my position. But please, no more sacrifice."
Next week looks Ab Aeterno awesome.
Letting Go: "The Candidate" - Recap by Robz888
Oh Lost, how you wound me. You tear out my heart and strap it to some C-4, leaving it inside a sinking submarine.
Even now, hours after my initial viewing, I'm still in shock, and more than a little depressed. Just Sayid dying would have been a tragedy in and of itself, without the even sadder Jin and Sun exit to top it off. Throw in Frank's demise (yes? maybe? too soon to call?), and I just can't take it.
Still, I have to hand it to the writers. They sure know how to make me simultaneously hate and love this show. I'm deeply saddened by what happened, but I can't deny that it made for a brilliant hour of television. In all honesty, this has to be one of the strongest episodes in all six seasons.
Before I get to the recap, let me offer a quick apology for not producing a proper recap of "The Last Recruit". I graduated from the University of Michigan last week, and I really just had a lot going on. By way of apology, I'll offer some brief thoughts on the episode before getting to "The Candidate".
Even now, hours after my initial viewing, I'm still in shock, and more than a little depressed. Just Sayid dying would have been a tragedy in and of itself, without the even sadder Jin and Sun exit to top it off. Throw in Frank's demise (yes? maybe? too soon to call?), and I just can't take it.
Still, I have to hand it to the writers. They sure know how to make me simultaneously hate and love this show. I'm deeply saddened by what happened, but I can't deny that it made for a brilliant hour of television. In all honesty, this has to be one of the strongest episodes in all six seasons.
Before I get to the recap, let me offer a quick apology for not producing a proper recap of "The Last Recruit". I graduated from the University of Michigan last week, and I really just had a lot going on. By way of apology, I'll offer some brief thoughts on the episode before getting to "The Candidate".
THE LAST RECRUIT... WAS WHO, EXACTLY?
Who is the Last Recruit? That's what I kept thinking. Were we just supposed to say, "Okay, yep. It's Jack."? And what was he being recruited for? Jack was the most hesitant about Sawyer's plan, and in the end opted not to follow it. And with the rescue from the tactical strike, it seemed like he had joined Flocke. Does this make him the last recruit to Flocke's dark army?
It's interesting that Jack is the new John, and the new character who looks like John despises his philosophy. Flocke calls John a "sucker" for believing that they were meant to stay on the island. He also reveals that he was the ghost of Christian Shephard all along. I'm inclined to believe that at this point, we won't ever get explanations for the Christian apparition in Jack's hospital or on the freighter, but based on what we've learned, I would have to guess that they were either the real ghost of Christian (remember that Hurley sees real ghosts all the time, so they do exist, maybe), or Jacob appearing as him (assuming Jacob has that power, which he may not). The ramifications of the Christian reveal are very interesting, though. Jack's father, the real John and the Man in Black all exist to some degree within the Flocke entity. We know Flocke has access to John's memories - what if he has Christian's, too? That would mean he knows an awful lot about Jack. Since I'm still wondering whether John has any influence over Flocke, I'm very intrigued by the idea of a triple (or even quadruple, if you think of Yemi, Alex Rousseau, etc...) persona entity.
Desmond is pretty creepy in the ATL. It seems like his goal is to get all the passengers to run into each other, hopefully channeling their memories of the other reality. But what will establishing these memories accomplish? Will our characters just throw up their arms and say, "Hey, that's weird! Oh well!" It can't be. There has to be a point to making them remember. Either this will have some discernible effect on the Island reality, or it will somehow negate the ATL reality.
Okay, I'm eager to tackle "The Candidate", so here we go.
It's interesting that Jack is the new John, and the new character who looks like John despises his philosophy. Flocke calls John a "sucker" for believing that they were meant to stay on the island. He also reveals that he was the ghost of Christian Shephard all along. I'm inclined to believe that at this point, we won't ever get explanations for the Christian apparition in Jack's hospital or on the freighter, but based on what we've learned, I would have to guess that they were either the real ghost of Christian (remember that Hurley sees real ghosts all the time, so they do exist, maybe), or Jacob appearing as him (assuming Jacob has that power, which he may not). The ramifications of the Christian reveal are very interesting, though. Jack's father, the real John and the Man in Black all exist to some degree within the Flocke entity. We know Flocke has access to John's memories - what if he has Christian's, too? That would mean he knows an awful lot about Jack. Since I'm still wondering whether John has any influence over Flocke, I'm very intrigued by the idea of a triple (or even quadruple, if you think of Yemi, Alex Rousseau, etc...) persona entity.
Desmond is pretty creepy in the ATL. It seems like his goal is to get all the passengers to run into each other, hopefully channeling their memories of the other reality. But what will establishing these memories accomplish? Will our characters just throw up their arms and say, "Hey, that's weird! Oh well!" It can't be. There has to be a point to making them remember. Either this will have some discernible effect on the Island reality, or it will somehow negate the ATL reality.
Okay, I'm eager to tackle "The Candidate", so here we go.
WELCOME TO HYDRA ISLAND
From the very start of this week's on-island plot, Sayid seemed less zombied, didn't he? His brief banter with Jack was a lot more alive than it would have been the day before. Remember the completely hollow way he said, "I don't feel anything"? Now, he's making jokes about having to paddle. Desmond's please-don't-shoot-me-brotha speech must have had an effect on him (and I'm going to guess that he didn't shoot the Scotsman, in any case). I would bet that events in the ATL also could have contributed to Sayid's different state of mind, but ATL Sayid has not yet had a major memory moment, and didn't seem to be going through anything during the ATL segments of "The Last Recruit" that would make him less of a zombie on the island.
On the other side of Hydra Island, basically everybody else is being put in the polar bear cages. The irony isn't lost on Sawyer, who grabs Seamus's gun and threatens to kill him. Widmore holds a gun to Kate's head and declares that he has no qualms about killing her, since she isn't on his list. This was an important admittance, which Sawyer confirms for Kate by telling her about the names on the cave walls. Apparently, Sawyer did notice that her name was there but crossed out. I was immediately concerned that Kate was in danger, but as it turned out, you were better off not being a candidate this week. Much better off.
The Smoke Monster attacks, kills several members of Widmore's team, including Seamus, who became the "Phil" of season 6. Jack helps them out of the cages, saying that he's with the Smoke Monster. I know it was only temporary, but still. Can you imagine watching the "Pilot" episode six years ago and being told that one day, Jack will aid the Smoke Monster?
Who's with who" has always been a dominant theme of Lost, but it's been even more pronounced this season. Even the titles "The Last Recruit" and "The Candidate" allude to membership and allegiance. The sides are constantly being redrawn, even as what each side stands for is being re-evaluated. After this episode, it will be hard to deny that Flocke is the "evil" side, but I don't know what that means for the "other" side. More on that later.
Speaking of who's with who, where were Widmore and Zoe during all of this? We don't find them at the plane or the sub. I'm guessing they paddled over to the main island, perhaps to look for Desmond, or even Richard.
On the other side of Hydra Island, basically everybody else is being put in the polar bear cages. The irony isn't lost on Sawyer, who grabs Seamus's gun and threatens to kill him. Widmore holds a gun to Kate's head and declares that he has no qualms about killing her, since she isn't on his list. This was an important admittance, which Sawyer confirms for Kate by telling her about the names on the cave walls. Apparently, Sawyer did notice that her name was there but crossed out. I was immediately concerned that Kate was in danger, but as it turned out, you were better off not being a candidate this week. Much better off.
The Smoke Monster attacks, kills several members of Widmore's team, including Seamus, who became the "Phil" of season 6. Jack helps them out of the cages, saying that he's with the Smoke Monster. I know it was only temporary, but still. Can you imagine watching the "Pilot" episode six years ago and being told that one day, Jack will aid the Smoke Monster?
Who's with who" has always been a dominant theme of Lost, but it's been even more pronounced this season. Even the titles "The Last Recruit" and "The Candidate" allude to membership and allegiance. The sides are constantly being redrawn, even as what each side stands for is being re-evaluated. After this episode, it will be hard to deny that Flocke is the "evil" side, but I don't know what that means for the "other" side. More on that later.
Speaking of who's with who, where were Widmore and Zoe during all of this? We don't find them at the plane or the sub. I'm guessing they paddled over to the main island, perhaps to look for Desmond, or even Richard.
THAT DARN C-4
Flocke easily commandeers the Ajira plane, which is barely guarded. Inside, he finds some C-4, ready to blow as soon as someone turns on the plane. He explains to the heroes that Widmore wanted them all to get in the plane and blow themselves up.
Flocke was pretty convincing, but based on later events in the episode, we know that this is not true - Flocke is the one who wanted to kill all of them. Widmore obviously doesn't want that, or else he would be working with Flocke, or would have just killed them himself. Why then would Widmore rig the plane with explosives? I'm tempted to believe that Flocke sneaked aboard the plane and put the explosives there himself, but then I don't know what the point of showing him discovering it was. Maybe for Widmore, keeping the candidates alive is important but not as important as just plain stopping Flocke from leaving the island, but then I would have expected the submarine to be rigged to blow, too.
In any case, the C-4 plays right into Flocke's hand. After auspiciously grabbing a watch off a dead guy, he explains that the plane is too dangerous and they'll have to steal the sub. Sawyer pretends to be with him (again), but immediately starts hatching a plan with Jack (again). Unfortunately, not only is Flocke expecting Sawyer's betrayal, he's counting on it.
Sawyer tells Jack to get Flocke in the water. I don't recall Flocke telling Sawyer that he's adverse to water, only that he can't fly over it in the smoke-form, so I was little surprised that Sawyer thought that would work. And I think the only reason it did work was because Flocke wanted them to escape - he took his time climbing back onto that dock.
Anyway, a shootout at the sub dock ensues. Jack shoves Flocke like he's supposed to, but Kate gets shot in the shoulder. Jack had maintained all episode that he wouldn't leave the island, but with Kate's injury, he hurries aboard the sub to help her. But if Kate hadn't been shot, I don't know that he would have gone aboard. I wonder if Flocke somehow influenced Kate getting shot. She's not a candidate, so he definitely could have harmed her. Actually, that may have been the whole point of Widmore and Sawyer bringing that fact up earlier in the episode. So Kate getting shot was either a very, very lucky occurrence for Flocke, or he somehow planned it.
Fearing that Flocke is going to try to come aboard, Sawyer shuts the door and orders the sub to dive, leaving Claire out on the dock. At the time I felt sorry for her being left behind again, but since this ultimately may have saved her life, it's not actually too sad.
Flocke was pretty convincing, but based on later events in the episode, we know that this is not true - Flocke is the one who wanted to kill all of them. Widmore obviously doesn't want that, or else he would be working with Flocke, or would have just killed them himself. Why then would Widmore rig the plane with explosives? I'm tempted to believe that Flocke sneaked aboard the plane and put the explosives there himself, but then I don't know what the point of showing him discovering it was. Maybe for Widmore, keeping the candidates alive is important but not as important as just plain stopping Flocke from leaving the island, but then I would have expected the submarine to be rigged to blow, too.
In any case, the C-4 plays right into Flocke's hand. After auspiciously grabbing a watch off a dead guy, he explains that the plane is too dangerous and they'll have to steal the sub. Sawyer pretends to be with him (again), but immediately starts hatching a plan with Jack (again). Unfortunately, not only is Flocke expecting Sawyer's betrayal, he's counting on it.
Sawyer tells Jack to get Flocke in the water. I don't recall Flocke telling Sawyer that he's adverse to water, only that he can't fly over it in the smoke-form, so I was little surprised that Sawyer thought that would work. And I think the only reason it did work was because Flocke wanted them to escape - he took his time climbing back onto that dock.
Anyway, a shootout at the sub dock ensues. Jack shoves Flocke like he's supposed to, but Kate gets shot in the shoulder. Jack had maintained all episode that he wouldn't leave the island, but with Kate's injury, he hurries aboard the sub to help her. But if Kate hadn't been shot, I don't know that he would have gone aboard. I wonder if Flocke somehow influenced Kate getting shot. She's not a candidate, so he definitely could have harmed her. Actually, that may have been the whole point of Widmore and Sawyer bringing that fact up earlier in the episode. So Kate getting shot was either a very, very lucky occurrence for Flocke, or he somehow planned it.
Fearing that Flocke is going to try to come aboard, Sawyer shuts the door and orders the sub to dive, leaving Claire out on the dock. At the time I felt sorry for her being left behind again, but since this ultimately may have saved her life, it's not actually too sad.
A CANDIDATE OF A DIFFERENT SORT
In the ATL, John wakes up from surgery and Jack explains that he fixed him. There's even more good news - John is a "candidate" for a new type of surgery that might fix John's initial spinal injury at minimum risk. To Jack's surprise and dismay, John says no.
Even though the reason for why John would want to stay in the wheel chair is revealed later (he's punishing himself), I think it could be something else, too. If John is having any flashes to the other reality, think about what he would see: a man duped into thinking he was special, finally betrayed by that false belief, his body used as a pawn by an evil entity. Depending upon how cognizant John is of that other life, he might be very wary of someone telling him that he's "special" in this life. I want John to be special, though, so I hope the surgery does end up happening.
But Jack doesn't take no for an answer, so he decides to investigate what caused John's injury. He tracks down the dentist who treated John in the wake of his accident, and unsurprisingly, it's a familiar face.
Sam Anderson did a great job this episode. Bernard seemed like he knew something, didn't he? We know that that "knowing" is very possible. He absolutely could have had the flashes like the ones that Desmond, Charlie and Daniel experienced. He also recognizes Jack from the Oceanic flight, and points this out, saying something about Jack flirting with his wife. I'm glad that some of the characters are finally addressing the fact that everybody was on the same plane.
Bernard steers Jack to Anthony Cooper, who's being visited by Helen. Cooper can't move or speak, as the result of the same accident that cost John his ability to walk.
Yes, Cooper looks pretty pitiable here, but don't start feeling sorry for him just yet. Consider: Cooper could be every bit the evil con man that he was in the MTL. The real question is whether John still has a kidney. If he does, this would lead me to believe that the accident happened before Cooper could complete his con. Cooper might have had every intention of discarding John like a piece of trash after getting the kidney, he just never got around to it. There's some proof of this, since Anthony Cooper appears to still be the man who caused the death of Sawyer's parents in this reality. He might not be reformed at all - he's just trapped and unable to speak because of the accident. I almost hope this is the case, or else I would feel sorry for him.
Even though the reason for why John would want to stay in the wheel chair is revealed later (he's punishing himself), I think it could be something else, too. If John is having any flashes to the other reality, think about what he would see: a man duped into thinking he was special, finally betrayed by that false belief, his body used as a pawn by an evil entity. Depending upon how cognizant John is of that other life, he might be very wary of someone telling him that he's "special" in this life. I want John to be special, though, so I hope the surgery does end up happening.
But Jack doesn't take no for an answer, so he decides to investigate what caused John's injury. He tracks down the dentist who treated John in the wake of his accident, and unsurprisingly, it's a familiar face.
Sam Anderson did a great job this episode. Bernard seemed like he knew something, didn't he? We know that that "knowing" is very possible. He absolutely could have had the flashes like the ones that Desmond, Charlie and Daniel experienced. He also recognizes Jack from the Oceanic flight, and points this out, saying something about Jack flirting with his wife. I'm glad that some of the characters are finally addressing the fact that everybody was on the same plane.
Bernard steers Jack to Anthony Cooper, who's being visited by Helen. Cooper can't move or speak, as the result of the same accident that cost John his ability to walk.
Yes, Cooper looks pretty pitiable here, but don't start feeling sorry for him just yet. Consider: Cooper could be every bit the evil con man that he was in the MTL. The real question is whether John still has a kidney. If he does, this would lead me to believe that the accident happened before Cooper could complete his con. Cooper might have had every intention of discarding John like a piece of trash after getting the kidney, he just never got around to it. There's some proof of this, since Anthony Cooper appears to still be the man who caused the death of Sawyer's parents in this reality. He might not be reformed at all - he's just trapped and unable to speak because of the accident. I almost hope this is the case, or else I would feel sorry for him.
LET THE WEEPING COMMENCE
Okay, I'm not sure I'm ready to relive this part of the episode yet, but here goes. Jack finds the C-4 that Flocke put in his pack. It's attached to the watch, and it's counting down with only a couple minutes to go. Sayid calculates that if both the wires are removed at the same time, the bomb may be disarmed.
Jack explains that if they do nothing, it won't go off, because Flocke can't kill them, despite what he said earlier in the episode. He also has the experience with Richard in the Black Rock to back him up. Jack correctly calculates that Flocke put them in a situation where they would do something to inadvertently kill each other. Here, Jack's faith is his defense. Unfortunately, it isn't enough for Sawyer, who pulls the wires and only speeds up the timer.
At first I thought this would violate the principal that Richard laid out in "Lighthouse", because Sawyer shouldn't be able to kill himself as a result of pulling the wires from the bomb, so it shouldn't have gone off. But if you think about it, this still holds to that rule, because Sawyer doesn't kill himself - he survives the explosion and the sub sinking. Instead of Sayid grabbing the C-4 and running into the other room, Sawyer should have simply thrown himself on top of it. That would have had to stop it, because Sawyer can't kill himself with the C-4 if we're still following Richard's rules. Instead, Sayid redeems himself and, completely unzombied, he tells Jack about Desmond, confides that it's going to be Jack, and runs off with the C-4 as it detonates.
We hardly have time to bid Sayid farewell (for the second time), as all hell breaks loose. Water rushes in, knocking out Frank. Sun is pinned. Sawyer is hit over the head. Hurley, who is a hero, I might add, rescues Kate and makes it out of the sub. Jack decides to save Sawyer. It was heart-breaking, absolutely heart-breaking watching the characters make these choices. Jack knows that he isn't going to see Jin and Sun again. He understands that Jin is going to die because of how much he loves Sun. It was heart-breaking. Watching people drown is absolutely agonizing. It was more emotional because Jin was free. If he had been pinned, too, it would have been different. But he was free to swim to safety, except he never even thinks about doing so. He isn't going to leave Sun, no matter what.
And so "The Candidate" becomes the first episode to kill more than 2 main characters in the same hour. Jin and Sun die shortly after their reunion - no happy ending for them, after all. In the end, we'll probably never know whether Sun or Jin was the candidate, and it doesn't even matter.
Jack explains that if they do nothing, it won't go off, because Flocke can't kill them, despite what he said earlier in the episode. He also has the experience with Richard in the Black Rock to back him up. Jack correctly calculates that Flocke put them in a situation where they would do something to inadvertently kill each other. Here, Jack's faith is his defense. Unfortunately, it isn't enough for Sawyer, who pulls the wires and only speeds up the timer.
At first I thought this would violate the principal that Richard laid out in "Lighthouse", because Sawyer shouldn't be able to kill himself as a result of pulling the wires from the bomb, so it shouldn't have gone off. But if you think about it, this still holds to that rule, because Sawyer doesn't kill himself - he survives the explosion and the sub sinking. Instead of Sayid grabbing the C-4 and running into the other room, Sawyer should have simply thrown himself on top of it. That would have had to stop it, because Sawyer can't kill himself with the C-4 if we're still following Richard's rules. Instead, Sayid redeems himself and, completely unzombied, he tells Jack about Desmond, confides that it's going to be Jack, and runs off with the C-4 as it detonates.
We hardly have time to bid Sayid farewell (for the second time), as all hell breaks loose. Water rushes in, knocking out Frank. Sun is pinned. Sawyer is hit over the head. Hurley, who is a hero, I might add, rescues Kate and makes it out of the sub. Jack decides to save Sawyer. It was heart-breaking, absolutely heart-breaking watching the characters make these choices. Jack knows that he isn't going to see Jin and Sun again. He understands that Jin is going to die because of how much he loves Sun. It was heart-breaking. Watching people drown is absolutely agonizing. It was more emotional because Jin was free. If he had been pinned, too, it would have been different. But he was free to swim to safety, except he never even thinks about doing so. He isn't going to leave Sun, no matter what.
And so "The Candidate" becomes the first episode to kill more than 2 main characters in the same hour. Jin and Sun die shortly after their reunion - no happy ending for them, after all. In the end, we'll probably never know whether Sun or Jin was the candidate, and it doesn't even matter.
A WORD ON FRANK
Concerning Frank, that was really, really ambiguous. There are a lot of reasons he's probably dead, and some reasons he might not be.
HE'S NOT DEAD: I would have expected them to at least show his body or something, if that was really it. I know he's not the most important character ever, but not to even dignify him with a confirm-able death is pretty cruel. And Jack, Kate and Hurley don't mention his name among the dead. Again, he isn't their best friend, but I would expect a little acknowledgment. Also, Frank (along with Richard) is the only main character with absolutely no flash-sideways counterpart. I'll admit that Frank has always been one of my favorites, so maybe my judgment is clouded, but it wouldn't surprise me if he washes up on shore. Jin did it in the wake of the freighter explosion, after all. This is Lost - if they want a character to inexplicably survive, the character will inexplicably survive.
HE'S DEAD: Then again, this is Lost. Let's return for a moment to the death of one of my other favorite semi-important characters, Ms. Danielle Rousseau. Sure, they left it ambiguous at first, but ultimately it didn't matter: she was dead. I feel like Frank probably just got the same treatment. He's not a candidate, they probably won't be leaving on the Ajira plane so they don't need a pilot... why keep him alive, when there's barely been anything for him to do all season? Really a bummer, though. I hope he's alive, anyway.
HE'S NOT DEAD: I would have expected them to at least show his body or something, if that was really it. I know he's not the most important character ever, but not to even dignify him with a confirm-able death is pretty cruel. And Jack, Kate and Hurley don't mention his name among the dead. Again, he isn't their best friend, but I would expect a little acknowledgment. Also, Frank (along with Richard) is the only main character with absolutely no flash-sideways counterpart. I'll admit that Frank has always been one of my favorites, so maybe my judgment is clouded, but it wouldn't surprise me if he washes up on shore. Jin did it in the wake of the freighter explosion, after all. This is Lost - if they want a character to inexplicably survive, the character will inexplicably survive.
HE'S DEAD: Then again, this is Lost. Let's return for a moment to the death of one of my other favorite semi-important characters, Ms. Danielle Rousseau. Sure, they left it ambiguous at first, but ultimately it didn't matter: she was dead. I feel like Frank probably just got the same treatment. He's not a candidate, they probably won't be leaving on the Ajira plane so they don't need a pilot... why keep him alive, when there's barely been anything for him to do all season? Really a bummer, though. I hope he's alive, anyway.
A WORD ON RICHARD, BEN AND MILES
When Richard (whose story is fully explained), Ben (who's been redeemed), and Miles (who doesn't seem to matter much) headed off on their expedition, I said to myself, "They're all dead. That's the group that gets slaughtered to the man." To borrow a line from my hero, John, "I was wrong!"
As it turns out, Hurley's plan to meet with Flocke was a terrible one. Richard had it right all along when he told Sawyer in "The Substitute" that Flocke meant to kill all of them. These deaths are the fault of Hurley for wanting to go to Flocke, Jack for backing him up, Sayid for turning off the fence, Sawyer for pulling the wires... and on and on. They've accidentally killed each other, which is unfortunately the only way Flocke can get them.
Anyway, I wonder what Richard's group is up to. It wouldn't surprise me if they meet up with Widmore and Zoe, and maybe even Desmond. Wouldn't it be cool for a Ben-Richard-Widmore reunion? Also, I'd love to see Ben and Desmond cross paths again.
As it turns out, Hurley's plan to meet with Flocke was a terrible one. Richard had it right all along when he told Sawyer in "The Substitute" that Flocke meant to kill all of them. These deaths are the fault of Hurley for wanting to go to Flocke, Jack for backing him up, Sayid for turning off the fence, Sawyer for pulling the wires... and on and on. They've accidentally killed each other, which is unfortunately the only way Flocke can get them.
Anyway, I wonder what Richard's group is up to. It wouldn't surprise me if they meet up with Widmore and Zoe, and maybe even Desmond. Wouldn't it be cool for a Ben-Richard-Widmore reunion? Also, I'd love to see Ben and Desmond cross paths again.
THREE REMAIN
Jack, Sawyer and Hurley are the only surviving candidates. According to Lostpedia, Jack, Hurley, Sawyer, Kate, Claire, Walt (and possibly Rose, Bernard and Vincent) are the only remaining survivors of the crash of Oceanic 815. That puts things in perspective, doesn't it? We've come such a long way.
Jack, Sawyer, Hurley and Kate wash up on the beach of what I assume is the main island and mourn their losses.
At the Hydra Island dock, Flocke is acutely aware that not all the candidates are dead. I know people are now attributing psychic powers to him, but he doesn't necessarily know which candidates survived. I think he might just be able to tell because he knows he isn't free yet.
Flocke is certainly evil, but I still maintain that that doesn't make Jacob good. It was on Michael's advice, wasn't it, that Hurley led them to Flocke? I was assuming that Michael was speaking on behalf of Jacob. Yet, it was this plan that resulted in all the deaths. I'm still very troubled by the way Jacob treats his followers.
As Flocke no doubt begins working on a scheme to rid himself of the rest of the candidates, his plan will probably concern Claire, and maybe Kate, too. The fact that Flocke can kill those two directly worries me greatly. And as Lost once again demonstrated, no one is safe.
Jack knows about Desmond now, and he knows it's going to be him. It's very likely that everyone else will die in the next four (and a half! did you here the good news?) hours, but Jack is going to live long enough to defeat the Man in Black once and for all.
Jack, Sawyer, Hurley and Kate wash up on the beach of what I assume is the main island and mourn their losses.
At the Hydra Island dock, Flocke is acutely aware that not all the candidates are dead. I know people are now attributing psychic powers to him, but he doesn't necessarily know which candidates survived. I think he might just be able to tell because he knows he isn't free yet.
Flocke is certainly evil, but I still maintain that that doesn't make Jacob good. It was on Michael's advice, wasn't it, that Hurley led them to Flocke? I was assuming that Michael was speaking on behalf of Jacob. Yet, it was this plan that resulted in all the deaths. I'm still very troubled by the way Jacob treats his followers.
As Flocke no doubt begins working on a scheme to rid himself of the rest of the candidates, his plan will probably concern Claire, and maybe Kate, too. The fact that Flocke can kill those two directly worries me greatly. And as Lost once again demonstrated, no one is safe.
Jack knows about Desmond now, and he knows it's going to be him. It's very likely that everyone else will die in the next four (and a half! did you here the good news?) hours, but Jack is going to live long enough to defeat the Man in Black once and for all.
THE REST OF THE ATL
As Jack listens to a sleeping John talking to himself ("push the button" and "I wish you had believed me" from his suicide note) Jack receives a visit from Claire. They learn that they shared a plane, and they take a look at the box that Christian left for Claire (the magic box!). Inside, they stare into a mirror as Catch a Falling Star plays.
When ATL characters look into mirrors, they appear to have some awareness of themselves in the island reality. Was this why Christian left it for them? Did he intend for them to open it together and see each others' reflections while recalling the island? This makes me wonder if the Christian Shephard whose body came to the island but was never found can somehow commune with his ATL dead self.
And finally, as John leaves the hospital, Jack learns of his accident. In yet another Emmy-deserving performance, John admits: "I was in a plane crash!" He had made his father his first passenger after getting his pilot's license, and disaster struck. John punishes himself for what happened, and is unwilling to have the surgery because he can't let go of it.
I was very intrigued by the revelation that ATL-John learned to fly planes. If the end of the ATL involves them all getting on a plane, maybe it will be John piloting it (this might also make Frank even less needed, unfortunately).
Jack tells John to let it go. During this speech, I felt like Jack was speaking to us, the Lost-obsessed fans. He was warning us that very soon, it's going to be time to move on - we'll have no choice. We'll have to go on with our lives without Lost.
It ends with little certainty that John will have the surgery, but I'm still hoping he will, eventually. Finale material, right?
As for the direction of the ATL as a whole, I'm really unsure. For the first half of the season, I thought, like many of you, that the ATL would simply serve as some sort of epilogue (which I wasn't thrilled with). But ever since Desmond's return, it's seemed like the ATL wasn't supposed to happen, and that by making everyone aware of the other reality, they would do something... and that something would lead to negation of the ATL, or a merging of the timelines. Now, I don't know again. Everybody in the island reality is dead. Are they really supposed to negate the much happier reality, however incorrect it may be?
Goodbye Sayid, Sun, Jin, and for good measure, Frank. As for our remaining heroes, please take care of yourselves.
Until next week,
- Robby "Robz888"
When ATL characters look into mirrors, they appear to have some awareness of themselves in the island reality. Was this why Christian left it for them? Did he intend for them to open it together and see each others' reflections while recalling the island? This makes me wonder if the Christian Shephard whose body came to the island but was never found can somehow commune with his ATL dead self.
And finally, as John leaves the hospital, Jack learns of his accident. In yet another Emmy-deserving performance, John admits: "I was in a plane crash!" He had made his father his first passenger after getting his pilot's license, and disaster struck. John punishes himself for what happened, and is unwilling to have the surgery because he can't let go of it.
I was very intrigued by the revelation that ATL-John learned to fly planes. If the end of the ATL involves them all getting on a plane, maybe it will be John piloting it (this might also make Frank even less needed, unfortunately).
Jack tells John to let it go. During this speech, I felt like Jack was speaking to us, the Lost-obsessed fans. He was warning us that very soon, it's going to be time to move on - we'll have no choice. We'll have to go on with our lives without Lost.
It ends with little certainty that John will have the surgery, but I'm still hoping he will, eventually. Finale material, right?
As for the direction of the ATL as a whole, I'm really unsure. For the first half of the season, I thought, like many of you, that the ATL would simply serve as some sort of epilogue (which I wasn't thrilled with). But ever since Desmond's return, it's seemed like the ATL wasn't supposed to happen, and that by making everyone aware of the other reality, they would do something... and that something would lead to negation of the ATL, or a merging of the timelines. Now, I don't know again. Everybody in the island reality is dead. Are they really supposed to negate the much happier reality, however incorrect it may be?
Goodbye Sayid, Sun, Jin, and for good measure, Frank. As for our remaining heroes, please take care of yourselves.
Until next week,
- Robby "Robz888"
Tuesday, May 4, 2010
Sean's Random Thoughts - LOST Recap - The Candidate
Here is Sean Furfaro's Recap of Tonight's Episode.
Breathe in...breathe out...breathe in...breathe out. No, I'm not singing Mat Kearney, and no, I'm not just making a predictable joke considering that the last third of this episode essentially took place underwater...I'm just catching my own breath. As I sit down to write this recap not even 10 minutes from the closing credits of "The Candidate", I'm still trying to make sense of it. I'll do my best...
As always, mouse over the pictures to see the captions below.
I used a hockey analogy in describing the pace of last week's episode. Well, if that was the end of a hockey game, then this was a drag race. Again, no "Previously on Lost" since we're going to need every minute in this hour, and we open with a shot of John Locke in the hospital in the FS World. Locke is greeted by Jack, and what ensues is an incredibly well-written scene, where every single word seemingly meant something in both realities. From Jack explaining to Locke that he may be a "candidate", to him declaring that he thinks he can "fix him", to Helen exclaiming "thank you for saving him."
Cut to Hydra Island in the Island World (now with Sayid as the official Hydra Island Greeter!), for a reversal of what we just saw. We cut from a scene where Jack has saved Locke, to a scene where (F)Locke has saved Jack. This scene's express purpose was to show that juxtaposition between the two, and to explain that Flocke, Sayid, and Jack are now on Hydra Island after traveling over in the outrigger.
Widmore's cronies marched our Losties to the cages that we all know only too well from Season 3, and despite some initial refusal from Sawyer (including calling Chip from Kate and Allie "doughboy") they ended up in the cage after Widmore threatened to kill Kate. Widmore rhymed off the names from "the list", which didn't include Kate, so he truthfully declared that he didn't care if she lived or died.
If you read my post from The Last Recruit, you'll remember that I introduced a concept of Mirror Imagery from previous episodes, and there were a number of them once again in this episode, so I'll start here with Mirror Image #1: Kate is threatened at gunpoint outside the cage in front of Sawyer, mirroring when Sawyer was threatened at gunpoint by Pickett outside the cage in front of Kate in the Season 3 episode "I Do." (alternate Mirror Image: Kate held at gunpoint by Juliet in front of Sawyer while they are building the runway in "The Glass Ballerina")
So it all comes full circle and now Kate and Sawyer are back in the land of the Fish Biscuit. But let's be honest, we weren't really expecting a hot and steamy Round 2 with them in that cage, were we? I mean, Sawyer is still presumably grieving Juliet (somehow), and there's no way they would put such a show on for all the others in there, right? The ones we should have been worries about were Jin and Sun after their reunion last week. Hey Widmore...If the cage is a rockin', don't come-a-knockin!
Back in the FS World, Jack pays a visit to Bernard's dental office snooping for info on John Locke. Bernard keeps his oath as a doctor (do dentist's still count?) and doesn't share confidential information, but still helps to steer Jack in the right direction, despite mentioning that he recalls Jack flirting with his wife on the plane. (What?!) Interesting that Jack told Bernard that he needed to fix John, while his Island persona seems to have released that need to fix everything.
Bernard seemed to have a "knowing" look in this scene(not the one in the picture above), and his tone of voice made me wonder if he was aware of both realities. When they realized the Oceanic 815 connection, Bernard said "Maybe you're on to something." And their last exchange seemed to mean more than it appeared on the surface alone:
Jack: "That was three years ago. You just remember that?"
Bernard: "Of course I do, Jack. (pause) Good luck, Doc. I hope you find what you're looking for."
Which is exactly what Kate told Jack in Episode 5 of this season, "The Lighthouse."
As we see Sayid and Jack on the beach on Hydra Island once again, we hear him tell Jack flat-out "Locke saved you." When Flocke joins them, Jack tells him that he's not sure he plans on joining him in his plan to leave the Island. Flocke says that he hopes Jack will change his mind, paralleling the FS World where Jack hopes that Locke will change his mind about the surgery. Flocke is unhappy about Jack's decision and launches into a tirade about how he could have killed Jack and everyone else...but didn't. I'm not sure that was the best way to build trust, it came across as pretty threatening.
In Cage-Land, Sawyer confirmed that Widmore was telling the truth about Kate not being on the list, and we saw a scene between Jin and Sun where they caught up on Ji-Yeon, pictures, and Jin's wedding band. I made a note watching that scene, that it seemed like a 'housekeeping' scene, just to neatly tie things up before the end. Boy, would that note come back to bite me in the ass...
Then the power cuts, we hear the tika-tika-tika that we all used to get exhilarated over, but now seem to respond to with significantly less excitement (am I wrong?), and the Smoke Monster is back in all of his delicious, Smokey form. Chip from Kate and Allie gets chucked into the cage, and lays there with the key dangling off his belt as Kate strains to reach it.
I had a problem with this scene, and it wasn't Frank's faux-heroic attempts to kick open the cage door. It's the fact that the last time Kate was in this cage, she climbed out of the cage through the top...but now's she reaching through the bars unable to get the key off of Chip's belt. Just as I'm yelling at my TV, Jack saves the day once again and unlocks the cage for them. As Kate asks what he's doing there, he responds with "I'm with him", echoing the end of last week's episode, but I didn't believe for a second that Jack was referring to anything other than proximity.
After the escape from the Cages, the Losties (with Flocke) make their way to the plane. Now, before I continue, I have to point out something that has been annoying me for the last couple of episodes. I'm not generally one to pick out continuity errors, but in the last couple of episodes, the day-night switching has just been lazy.
Last week's episode ends in the daytime with Widmore and Zoe taking the Losties hostage, but this week as they were walking to the Cages, it was night. Are we to believe that in the time it took Flocke, Jack, and Sayid to recover from the attack, and paddle over to Hydra Island, as it switched from day to night...that's how long it took Zoe and the Losties to walk from the beach to the Cages? Come on! And then after the nighttime escape from the cages, it's suddenly daytime on the way to the plane?
But back to the story, where in the FS World, Jack continued his creepy ways by tracking down Anthony Cooper. As he ran into Helen in the lobby and explained that he wanted to help, she told him to "leave this alone", but then his response to her was the good old Jack Shepherd we've always known:
Helen: "You saved John's life. Why can't that be enough?"
Jack: "Because it's not."
And as we saw Anthony Cooper for the first time , we didn't see the sleazeball con man we knew him to be...we saw a catatonic creature in a wheelchair (nice touch). It made me think of Ben and Roger in the FS World...and how both Ben and Locke had been cursed with horrible fathers previously, but now the situation was quite different for both of them.
At the Ajira plane, the two "guards" fired on Flocke, and were summarily dismissed. I have to think back to earlier this season, when Bram fired on Flocke and was killed, and then when Ilana cocked her gun when he came out of the statue, Richard instructed her NOT to shoot. Is this the theory I posed earlier, that he can act only when directly threatened? It still doesn't explain the Oceanic 815 pilot or the Temple dwellers, but it may be something...
I saw him take the watch from the dead guard, and then find the explosives in the plane, and I was disappointed that I knew what would be coming...
One question I have about when the Losties arrived at the Ajira plane, was how come we didn't get a scene of Sawyer and Kate looking at each other and saying, "So that's what we were building the damn runway for!" And I actually laughed out loud when Sayid diagnosed the dead guard..."He's got a broken neck." If anyone knows about snappin' necks, it's Sayid.
As they left the Ajira plane, Jack held firm to his insistence that he would not be leaving, and even though Flocke said "fair enough", I didn't buy it for a second. Claire then apologized to Flocke for deserting him earlier, and he gave her a forgiving pat on the back and told her he understood why she did it. He still seemed protective of her, and it made me think of something in terms of how they all refer to the entity I call Flocke or the Man in Black (MIB).
Have you notice that those that trust him, and are "with" him, refer to him as "Locke", or"him", or in Claire's case, even "my friend"...but those that don't trust him, refer to him as "it", or "that thing", or something similar. It's almost as if not trusting him gives them an inability to personalize how he/it is viewed.
In the FS World, Locke woke up in his hospital bed saying "Push the button", and "I wish you had believed me." In an effort to keep this recap to a reasonable length, I'll let you take that one in the Comments section, because I could write a whole post on that.
But out in the waiting area, Jack talked to Claire and we saw Mirror Image #3: where Jack purchased a candy bar in the hospital vending machine and offered in to Claire, mirroring what we saw in the Season 5 finale "The Incident", where Jacob did the same with Jack.
And as Claire explained to Jack that she too was on Oceanic 815, it seemed as if Jack was starting to realize that something was going on after finding out the same thing with Bernard, but we were sidetracked with Claire's gift from Christian, a music box that was playing "Catch a Falling Star." I was expecting that song to be a trigger for one or both of them, but it wasn't.
As the Losties prepared to storm the sub, I watched Sawyer barrel his way down on to the dock and onto the sub like he was a cast member in Stomp, and even though I have no experience inside a submarine, I have to wonder how on earth the crew inside didn't hear them coming. Just before Jack and Flocke headed down, I saw Flocke hand Jack his knapsack, and while I couldn't tell if he switched them or just made sure Jack had his, I knew what it meant. Why the hell did he take that watch?
On the way to the sub, Jack knocked Flocke into the water as Sawyer had instructed, leading all of us Lost junkies to scream thinking that the long-standing theory that Flocke was weakened by water was about to be confirmed. Um...not so much. Credit to Damon and Carlton for the knowing wink from Sawyer telling Jack to "get it in the water", but it appears it was just a stall tactic.
Then my beloved Kate got shot and my jaw dropped. No way! I was too shocked to immediately recognize that I was seeing Mirror Image #4: the shootout at the sub that saw Kate shot and hustled into the sub, mirroring The Incident, where we saw Sayid shot and hustled into the Dharma Van.
As the shootout continued furiously outside the sub, we saw Sawyer go back for Claire, but when he saw Flocke coming for the boat, he abandoned her yet again, locking them both out. Little did she know that this time, she was actually saved, as Flocke told her "You don't want to be on that sub."
The bomb scene on the sub was reminiscent of the scene between Jack and Richard in the Black Rock...it was all about trust. And as Jack explained that they just had to trust him, that they were all going to be ok if they just let the counter click down...I believed him, and I believed him 100%. Did you?
Jack was bang-on in his assessment that the goal by Flocke was for them to kill each other, which is what they would be doing by messing with the bomb. And just as Jack has become the Faithful, like Locke...Sawyer has now become the Non-Believer, like Jack once was.
As the bomb ticked down furiously, Sayid grabbed it and gave Jack a message about Desmond on the Island, and how Jack would need him. His last line before running off with the bomb was "It's going to be you, Jack", which I can only imagine refers to the title of the episode, 'The Candidate", and that Jack will be the one to replace Jacob.
Very few scenes in this show give me full on goosebumps anymore, but Sayid's slow-motion run through the submarine before blowing up was one of them. Just when I thought I didn't care what happened to him...wow.
The sequences on the sub all happened so fast that I can't really take them all in without a second or third viewing. Frank gets a door blown in his face (mirroring Jack on Hydra Island?), Jack screams "There is no Sayid!", Hurley tries to get Kate to safety, Jack leaves with Sawyer, but then it all came down to Jin and Sun.
Now I've been very vocal with the use of these two characters this season, and what I perceived as their uselessness, and that they were a love story that I just wasn't buying into. But as I watched the water rise to Jin's chin, and saw Jack leave them alone on the sub, and remember back to what I called the "housekeeping" scene in the cage...it became clear what I was watching.
And I lost it. If you would have told me I would be bawling my eyes out at Jin and Sun drowning, I would have scoffed at you, but that's the damn magic of this show. They remind you that just when you think you don't care anymore, you still do. I'll leave more accomplished recappers like Vozzek and Jeff Jensen to break down that scene, but if you weren't emotional in that closing shot of the hands separating with the flashing red light behind and the musical score playing, I would argue that you don't have a heart.
But as I shook off the emotion of that scene, and watched the show switch back to Locke in the FS World, I found myself wondering if perhaps Locke was responsible for Cooper's condition...and that's why he didn't want to talk about it. And in that closing FS scene between Jack and Locke, that appears to be what we are being led to believe, but I think it's something else...
Did you notice that when Locke saw Jin in the hospital hallway, he paused as if he recognized him? I'm now wondering if the Locke we are seeing in the FS World is indeed the Man in Black, and he too has traveled between the two realities. It would make sense that he would refuse the surgery, because he would NEED John Locke to not be able to walk, so that the Island would still give him his faith once he was there. Make sense? Probably not...it's getting late and I'm clearly starting to ramble.
Jack and Locke talked fathers, letting go, and "what happened, happened", and then in a final un-Locke-like laugh, John rolled away as Jack called after him "I wish you believed me." Mirror Image #5: this is the same message from John to Jack in "The Life and Death of Jeremy Bentham."
The surviving Losties, Jack, Hurley, Sawyer, and a wounded Kate reconvene on the beach where Hurley breaks down, and Jack seemingly acknowledges that his faith is being tested.
Then we switch to Claire and Flocke, and somehow the MIB knows that the sub sunk, and not everyone is dead...and stomps off "to finish what I started."
Body Count: Sun, Jin, Sayid, Chip from Kate and Allie, a number of randoms, and possibly Frank. Quite a statement for one episode.
You can breathe now...
Until next week.
Breathe in...breathe out...breathe in...breathe out. No, I'm not singing Mat Kearney, and no, I'm not just making a predictable joke considering that the last third of this episode essentially took place underwater...I'm just catching my own breath. As I sit down to write this recap not even 10 minutes from the closing credits of "The Candidate", I'm still trying to make sense of it. I'll do my best...As always, mouse over the pictures to see the captions below.
I used a hockey analogy in describing the pace of last week's episode. Well, if that was the end of a hockey game, then this was a drag race. Again, no "Previously on Lost" since we're going to need every minute in this hour, and we open with a shot of John Locke in the hospital in the FS World. Locke is greeted by Jack, and what ensues is an incredibly well-written scene, where every single word seemingly meant something in both realities. From Jack explaining to Locke that he may be a "candidate", to him declaring that he thinks he can "fix him", to Helen exclaiming "thank you for saving him."
Cut to Hydra Island in the Island World (now with Sayid as the official Hydra Island Greeter!), for a reversal of what we just saw. We cut from a scene where Jack has saved Locke, to a scene where (F)Locke has saved Jack. This scene's express purpose was to show that juxtaposition between the two, and to explain that Flocke, Sayid, and Jack are now on Hydra Island after traveling over in the outrigger. Widmore's cronies marched our Losties to the cages that we all know only too well from Season 3, and despite some initial refusal from Sawyer (including calling Chip from Kate and Allie "doughboy") they ended up in the cage after Widmore threatened to kill Kate. Widmore rhymed off the names from "the list", which didn't include Kate, so he truthfully declared that he didn't care if she lived or died.
If you read my post from The Last Recruit, you'll remember that I introduced a concept of Mirror Imagery from previous episodes, and there were a number of them once again in this episode, so I'll start here with Mirror Image #1: Kate is threatened at gunpoint outside the cage in front of Sawyer, mirroring when Sawyer was threatened at gunpoint by Pickett outside the cage in front of Kate in the Season 3 episode "I Do." (alternate Mirror Image: Kate held at gunpoint by Juliet in front of Sawyer while they are building the runway in "The Glass Ballerina")
So it all comes full circle and now Kate and Sawyer are back in the land of the Fish Biscuit. But let's be honest, we weren't really expecting a hot and steamy Round 2 with them in that cage, were we? I mean, Sawyer is still presumably grieving Juliet (somehow), and there's no way they would put such a show on for all the others in there, right? The ones we should have been worries about were Jin and Sun after their reunion last week. Hey Widmore...If the cage is a rockin', don't come-a-knockin! Back in the FS World, Jack pays a visit to Bernard's dental office snooping for info on John Locke. Bernard keeps his oath as a doctor (do dentist's still count?) and doesn't share confidential information, but still helps to steer Jack in the right direction, despite mentioning that he recalls Jack flirting with his wife on the plane. (What?!) Interesting that Jack told Bernard that he needed to fix John, while his Island persona seems to have released that need to fix everything.
Bernard seemed to have a "knowing" look in this scene(not the one in the picture above), and his tone of voice made me wonder if he was aware of both realities. When they realized the Oceanic 815 connection, Bernard said "Maybe you're on to something." And their last exchange seemed to mean more than it appeared on the surface alone: Jack: "That was three years ago. You just remember that?"
Bernard: "Of course I do, Jack. (pause) Good luck, Doc. I hope you find what you're looking for."
Which is exactly what Kate told Jack in Episode 5 of this season, "The Lighthouse."
As we see Sayid and Jack on the beach on Hydra Island once again, we hear him tell Jack flat-out "Locke saved you." When Flocke joins them, Jack tells him that he's not sure he plans on joining him in his plan to leave the Island. Flocke says that he hopes Jack will change his mind, paralleling the FS World where Jack hopes that Locke will change his mind about the surgery. Flocke is unhappy about Jack's decision and launches into a tirade about how he could have killed Jack and everyone else...but didn't. I'm not sure that was the best way to build trust, it came across as pretty threatening.
In Cage-Land, Sawyer confirmed that Widmore was telling the truth about Kate not being on the list, and we saw a scene between Jin and Sun where they caught up on Ji-Yeon, pictures, and Jin's wedding band. I made a note watching that scene, that it seemed like a 'housekeeping' scene, just to neatly tie things up before the end. Boy, would that note come back to bite me in the ass...
Then the power cuts, we hear the tika-tika-tika that we all used to get exhilarated over, but now seem to respond to with significantly less excitement (am I wrong?), and the Smoke Monster is back in all of his delicious, Smokey form. Chip from Kate and Allie gets chucked into the cage, and lays there with the key dangling off his belt as Kate strains to reach it. I had a problem with this scene, and it wasn't Frank's faux-heroic attempts to kick open the cage door. It's the fact that the last time Kate was in this cage, she climbed out of the cage through the top...but now's she reaching through the bars unable to get the key off of Chip's belt. Just as I'm yelling at my TV, Jack saves the day once again and unlocks the cage for them. As Kate asks what he's doing there, he responds with "I'm with him", echoing the end of last week's episode, but I didn't believe for a second that Jack was referring to anything other than proximity.
After the escape from the Cages, the Losties (with Flocke) make their way to the plane. Now, before I continue, I have to point out something that has been annoying me for the last couple of episodes. I'm not generally one to pick out continuity errors, but in the last couple of episodes, the day-night switching has just been lazy. Last week's episode ends in the daytime with Widmore and Zoe taking the Losties hostage, but this week as they were walking to the Cages, it was night. Are we to believe that in the time it took Flocke, Jack, and Sayid to recover from the attack, and paddle over to Hydra Island, as it switched from day to night...that's how long it took Zoe and the Losties to walk from the beach to the Cages? Come on! And then after the nighttime escape from the cages, it's suddenly daytime on the way to the plane?
But back to the story, where in the FS World, Jack continued his creepy ways by tracking down Anthony Cooper. As he ran into Helen in the lobby and explained that he wanted to help, she told him to "leave this alone", but then his response to her was the good old Jack Shepherd we've always known:
Helen: "You saved John's life. Why can't that be enough?"
Jack: "Because it's not."
And as we saw Anthony Cooper for the first time , we didn't see the sleazeball con man we knew him to be...we saw a catatonic creature in a wheelchair (nice touch). It made me think of Ben and Roger in the FS World...and how both Ben and Locke had been cursed with horrible fathers previously, but now the situation was quite different for both of them.
At the Ajira plane, the two "guards" fired on Flocke, and were summarily dismissed. I have to think back to earlier this season, when Bram fired on Flocke and was killed, and then when Ilana cocked her gun when he came out of the statue, Richard instructed her NOT to shoot. Is this the theory I posed earlier, that he can act only when directly threatened? It still doesn't explain the Oceanic 815 pilot or the Temple dwellers, but it may be something... I saw him take the watch from the dead guard, and then find the explosives in the plane, and I was disappointed that I knew what would be coming...
One question I have about when the Losties arrived at the Ajira plane, was how come we didn't get a scene of Sawyer and Kate looking at each other and saying, "So that's what we were building the damn runway for!" And I actually laughed out loud when Sayid diagnosed the dead guard..."He's got a broken neck." If anyone knows about snappin' necks, it's Sayid.
As they left the Ajira plane, Jack held firm to his insistence that he would not be leaving, and even though Flocke said "fair enough", I didn't buy it for a second. Claire then apologized to Flocke for deserting him earlier, and he gave her a forgiving pat on the back and told her he understood why she did it. He still seemed protective of her, and it made me think of something in terms of how they all refer to the entity I call Flocke or the Man in Black (MIB). Have you notice that those that trust him, and are "with" him, refer to him as "Locke", or"him", or in Claire's case, even "my friend"...but those that don't trust him, refer to him as "it", or "that thing", or something similar. It's almost as if not trusting him gives them an inability to personalize how he/it is viewed.
In the FS World, Locke woke up in his hospital bed saying "Push the button", and "I wish you had believed me." In an effort to keep this recap to a reasonable length, I'll let you take that one in the Comments section, because I could write a whole post on that.
But out in the waiting area, Jack talked to Claire and we saw Mirror Image #3: where Jack purchased a candy bar in the hospital vending machine and offered in to Claire, mirroring what we saw in the Season 5 finale "The Incident", where Jacob did the same with Jack.
And as Claire explained to Jack that she too was on Oceanic 815, it seemed as if Jack was starting to realize that something was going on after finding out the same thing with Bernard, but we were sidetracked with Claire's gift from Christian, a music box that was playing "Catch a Falling Star." I was expecting that song to be a trigger for one or both of them, but it wasn't.
As the Losties prepared to storm the sub, I watched Sawyer barrel his way down on to the dock and onto the sub like he was a cast member in Stomp, and even though I have no experience inside a submarine, I have to wonder how on earth the crew inside didn't hear them coming. Just before Jack and Flocke headed down, I saw Flocke hand Jack his knapsack, and while I couldn't tell if he switched them or just made sure Jack had his, I knew what it meant. Why the hell did he take that watch?
On the way to the sub, Jack knocked Flocke into the water as Sawyer had instructed, leading all of us Lost junkies to scream thinking that the long-standing theory that Flocke was weakened by water was about to be confirmed. Um...not so much. Credit to Damon and Carlton for the knowing wink from Sawyer telling Jack to "get it in the water", but it appears it was just a stall tactic.
Then my beloved Kate got shot and my jaw dropped. No way! I was too shocked to immediately recognize that I was seeing Mirror Image #4: the shootout at the sub that saw Kate shot and hustled into the sub, mirroring The Incident, where we saw Sayid shot and hustled into the Dharma Van.
As the shootout continued furiously outside the sub, we saw Sawyer go back for Claire, but when he saw Flocke coming for the boat, he abandoned her yet again, locking them both out. Little did she know that this time, she was actually saved, as Flocke told her "You don't want to be on that sub."
The bomb scene on the sub was reminiscent of the scene between Jack and Richard in the Black Rock...it was all about trust. And as Jack explained that they just had to trust him, that they were all going to be ok if they just let the counter click down...I believed him, and I believed him 100%. Did you?
Jack was bang-on in his assessment that the goal by Flocke was for them to kill each other, which is what they would be doing by messing with the bomb. And just as Jack has become the Faithful, like Locke...Sawyer has now become the Non-Believer, like Jack once was.
As the bomb ticked down furiously, Sayid grabbed it and gave Jack a message about Desmond on the Island, and how Jack would need him. His last line before running off with the bomb was "It's going to be you, Jack", which I can only imagine refers to the title of the episode, 'The Candidate", and that Jack will be the one to replace Jacob.
Very few scenes in this show give me full on goosebumps anymore, but Sayid's slow-motion run through the submarine before blowing up was one of them. Just when I thought I didn't care what happened to him...wow.
The sequences on the sub all happened so fast that I can't really take them all in without a second or third viewing. Frank gets a door blown in his face (mirroring Jack on Hydra Island?), Jack screams "There is no Sayid!", Hurley tries to get Kate to safety, Jack leaves with Sawyer, but then it all came down to Jin and Sun. Now I've been very vocal with the use of these two characters this season, and what I perceived as their uselessness, and that they were a love story that I just wasn't buying into. But as I watched the water rise to Jin's chin, and saw Jack leave them alone on the sub, and remember back to what I called the "housekeeping" scene in the cage...it became clear what I was watching.
And I lost it. If you would have told me I would be bawling my eyes out at Jin and Sun drowning, I would have scoffed at you, but that's the damn magic of this show. They remind you that just when you think you don't care anymore, you still do. I'll leave more accomplished recappers like Vozzek and Jeff Jensen to break down that scene, but if you weren't emotional in that closing shot of the hands separating with the flashing red light behind and the musical score playing, I would argue that you don't have a heart.
But as I shook off the emotion of that scene, and watched the show switch back to Locke in the FS World, I found myself wondering if perhaps Locke was responsible for Cooper's condition...and that's why he didn't want to talk about it. And in that closing FS scene between Jack and Locke, that appears to be what we are being led to believe, but I think it's something else... Did you notice that when Locke saw Jin in the hospital hallway, he paused as if he recognized him? I'm now wondering if the Locke we are seeing in the FS World is indeed the Man in Black, and he too has traveled between the two realities. It would make sense that he would refuse the surgery, because he would NEED John Locke to not be able to walk, so that the Island would still give him his faith once he was there. Make sense? Probably not...it's getting late and I'm clearly starting to ramble.
Jack and Locke talked fathers, letting go, and "what happened, happened", and then in a final un-Locke-like laugh, John rolled away as Jack called after him "I wish you believed me." Mirror Image #5: this is the same message from John to Jack in "The Life and Death of Jeremy Bentham." The surviving Losties, Jack, Hurley, Sawyer, and a wounded Kate reconvene on the beach where Hurley breaks down, and Jack seemingly acknowledges that his faith is being tested.
Then we switch to Claire and Flocke, and somehow the MIB knows that the sub sunk, and not everyone is dead...and stomps off "to finish what I started." Body Count: Sun, Jin, Sayid, Chip from Kate and Allie, a number of randoms, and possibly Frank. Quite a statement for one episode.
You can breathe now...
Until next week.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
